[Rumil]

Interesting thread!

While there are some obvious parallels with the Greek (and by extension, Roman) Gods, eg Vulcan-Aule, Neptune-Ulmo, they seem to me to be about the 'area of responsibility' of each deity rather than their characters.

In character the Valar appear more similar to the Angels and Archangels of Christianity (and Milton), more serious-minded, and not running around seducing princesses while disguised as wildlife. And likely less fun than Dionysus at a party!

I noticed the Norse gods were brought up. In a way Tulkas reminded me of Thor (though without the lightning bolts etc), being similarly forthright characters.

Does anyone recognise the Valar in other Pantheons at all?

The Celtic gods seem a bit nebuous and tricky to tie down but Hindu perhaps? I'm afraid I know too little!