[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Eönwë

I have noticed, though, that everone the phantom has voted (or been "playful" with, and by that I mean Mith) has died. Be careful Fea.

1) Careful isn't one of my strong points.

2) The phantom isn't likely to kill me until later, if he's going to kill me at all. And of course he's going to try to kill me. If he's a wolf, he has to. If he's a cobbler, he'd like to. And if he's a villager, he'll kill everybody else to ascertain victory because one innocent standing is still a microcosmic victory for the entire village, and knowing him, he's likely to propose that we whittle ourselves away until he's the last one standing, at which point he will shout his true identity and we'll see who won. Point being, I doubt he'll try to kill me yet. You? You might be in more trouble. Chances are, Shasta's in bigger trouble than you. Me? I'm pretty safe.

Originally Posted by Greenie about Form

I've never played with him before (?) so I can't compare his behaviour to what he usually is like.

He's usually not quite this playful, and more verbose. Dead Serious is a very appropriate pt.

Originally Posted by Greenie

Kath - No read.

I know, right? Kath, why are you so invisible? I need you, Kath, I want you! Come jump around in the spotlight for a little while so I can judge you.

Originally Posted by Kath

But really, who are you going to dream of as a Seer when you have phantom and Fea, masters at playing you for a fool? Thought so.

Aww! You're right, though. But Gwath doesn't know me as well as others. It's quite possible he took me for granted. But there's the obvious other choice, which I'd take as a seer playing against myself: I'd not bother with the phantom and Fea, knowing they'd probably just get themselves lynched anyway. Why waste dreams on conspicuous people? Dream of low profile folk who don't garner votes, and can hide. Dream of the people who have no evidence mounting against them otherwise. If I was seer, I'd be dreaming little dreams. Me and the phantom? Masters we are, but I wouldn't dream of either of us.

Originally Posted by the phantom

Seriously Eonwe- try and think your arguments through before you post them. You can't just pick someone to go after despite all the facts.

Maybe he did think through the argument and posted anyway because cobblers enjoy confusing people.

Originally Posted by the phantom

Will someone please suggest a scenario where an Ordo Kath would spout nonsense like this? Because I'd really like to lynch her. Really.

Scenario: Ordo Kath has not been around as often as is usual. Consequently, when she reads, she skims to keep up. Adding to the high paced read through, she has prior knowledge of several players. The phantom and Fea are not new to her: she knows that she would dream of them. She posits the theory while she has time, with the idea to come back later and think a bit harder.

Lynch her anyway?