On day 1
Eönwë accuses
Nerwen purely in character, and says she isn't doing anything useful, suggesting she's the spammer (though he also suggests that
Nilp or
Form is the spammer). He's a bit jumpy and says my accidental twisting of his words sounds wolfish.
He voted for
Mith that day because she looked like she was half hiding behind her character and her attitude seemed slightly suspicious.
He continues being jumpy on day 2, but innocentishly so. He didn't suspect
Mith as much anymore then - he thought she needed monitoring, but there were much more suspicious people around. He found
EW the most suspicious for voting him without a reason after two others had done so, although he mentioned that
Ka didn't seem to suspect him, either, but voted still. He voted for
EW, and commented it seemed like he had become a suspicious character lately.
If he was a wolf from the beginning, I'll eat my head. There's something genuinely honest in those posts of his, and besides he voted for
Mith on day 1. I don't want to underestimate a possible
Eönwolf, but it would be an extremely bold move to vote for his fellow on day 1 in his first game as a wolf.
Okay, then day 3 when the new wolf was turned.
He's seemingly surprised by the
Kath kill, but agrees that she left little trails. He thinks the extra wolf might not be easy to find, but hope shouldn't be abandoned. In his opinion, the person with the biggest change was
Shasta, who was, if not silent, at least laid back, but was on day 3 lively and engaged in conversation. It didn't mean he was wolfish, though - the change might have been just because of time restraints.
Then he disappeared for hours and was back to vote for
Nilp (who had 2 votes already), promising to explain it when he can.
On day 4
Eönwë replied to
Boro's question about
Dur saying she wants to look at
Kit, asking if he had considered that
Durelin would have just wanted to hide her identity by not naming the wolves, since if she had dreamed of her, a radical change of mind would look suspicious. This looks unlikely to me, and though I agreed with him then, my suspicion on
Kitanna has lessened since. Somehow he looks like he's trying not to let suspicions on
Kitanna fall.
I asked him to explain his vote for
Nilp since he had promised to do it, and he said he didn't really know why he voted - it was more of a feeling. If he had been there at deadline, he would probably have voted for
Mith. This is the first thing about him that I think is a bit suspicious.
Mith had attracted so much suspicion on day 3 that it would make sense if the wolves had decided to sacrifice her after that.
Eönwë might have wanted to make himself look better by saying that - but on the other hand he had been suspicious of her from the beginning (although he didn't mention her at all on day 3). Though if I remember correctly,
Mith didn't have any votes by the time
Eönwë voted whereas also
Eönwë himself had one, so his
Nilp vote might also have been for self-preservation.
In the same post he said that
Shasta and
Eomer seem suspicious, but he hopes they are "
as innocent as they are entertaining".
He suspects
Eomer for not voting
Mith:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Eönwë
And how come Eomer is not voting Mithalwen?
He kept on saying how suspicious he was of her on the first two days, but then on the next two he votes Nilp and today he votes Shasta, specifically avoiding voting Mith. Is he our innocent-turned-wolf?
|
Now, now... There should be nothing suspicious in changing one's mind. This post suggests
Eomer became a wolf and
was informed Mith is his fellow.
Eönwë accuses someone of not voting for a wolf
before Mith's role is revealed to the village. Whoa.
Thus far I've been more inclined to think
Eönwë could be innocent, after all, but not anymore after this one. Or, say, his innocence became just much less likely.
Then he votes for
Mith himself. His main suspects were
Mith,
Shasta,
Nogrod,
Eomer, and maybe
Kitanna, who was sometimes suspicious and sometimes not at all.
He replies to
Nogrod's comment on his eyebrow-raising habit of not reading posts by asking if it wouldn't be too obvious even for him, if a wolf.
Day 4 is the last day he's really vocal. Only eight of his 57 posts were written during three last days.
On day 5
Eönwë agrees with
Nogrod about
Shasta being suspicious - he looks like he was trying to save
Mith.
Nog seems to be making a lot sense, but he doesn't know if that means he's a wolf trying to look good. After
Shasta's revelation he jokingly (IC) suggests that both
Shasta and
Eomer are wolves who are just trying to look like gifteds, and ends his post by saying he seemingly got a bit carried away. That day he didn't vote, and tells later that his internet died. Now, tell me,
Eönwë, who would you have voted, and why?
On day 6 he votes for
Boro, notes that he has become a chief suspect, explains not voting and asks how he is connected to the
Kath kill.
**
On days 1 & 2
Boro says
Eönwë looks innocent.
On day 2
Mith says
Eönwë could be the spammer.
On day 1,
Nerwen votes for
Eönwë when there was the risk that either she or
Mith might have been lynched.
**
He doesn't look very suspicious after day 2, either, although more than on the first few days. But there are some things that really make me uncomfortable, like that quote I posted. And also that
Mith thing - suspecting, not mentioning, suspecting again. But somehow I don't like the thought that he was turned in night 3 - or then
Boro just is a damn good wolf and a horrible backstabber.
I think I could take the risk of lynching
Eönwë today, and if he's not the wolf, my next choice would be
Rikae.
Off to take my friend's dog for a walk (that's the price I have to pay for being allowed to stay at her home while she's fencing).
edit: xed with two Kits