Quote:
Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim
Remember Loki?
|
Oh, that was the most stinging "I told you so" ever said by anyone in a Werewolf game.
After having skimmed through the first DWW (goodness, it took me hours! I almost want to commit suicide again!
), I have a few things to say, just to get things off my shoulders:
1. Just to clarify, either wizard cannot refuse a duel once the other challenges. Right? But they do have the choice not to challenge right away even if the identity of the other is already revealed to them.
2. Yes, I think it would be better if the player scried by both wizards is killed. I don't know how we'll all react if this happens again. *points up*
3. I agree that the GW should also be given three players to scry on Night 1. (And trust
Mac to know his maths - the Night 1 scry list should indeed include more than 5 people.)
4. I go with the standard 3 wolves = 1 Night kill, and then maybe just add one kill for each added wolf? Would that sway the balance too much? If so then maybe there can be 2 Night kills for 4 to 6 wolves. I seriously hope we don't get more than 6 wolves at a time!
5. 7 AM (my time) deadline should be good, that will give me the night to catch up. (Who needs to study, do homework, and sleep?)
6. Sorry, I must be really dim, but when are wizards and minions allowed to communicate again?
7. I still say no to retractable votes. Double lynches...hmm...is it not enough that there's a possibility that more than one person could be killed at Night? And we're not always wise with our lynch victims (understatement of the year). I'll go with no.
8. Perhaps
Eomer would consent to be sub-mod? Oh, no, that would be weirder than he and
Cailin playing together. Forget I mentioned it.
9. I'd like to be an
apprentice healer. Will someone take and train me?
10.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
If the EW gets everything right and luck favours her she will get the sixth wolf on Day4. Then the total of villagers will be about -6 from the starting line-up. So from 30 it will be 24/6, from 25 it will be 19/6 (1/3 being 18/6). But it's not probable the EW will get everything her way...
|
But by then there will already have been several lynches and Night kills...won't the Bad Team be in too much of an advantage?
The GW could be limited to the three Gifteds, and other scries can be Ranger protections (except if the EW also scries that person, of course) or de-wolfings. Once a Gifted is ungifted or killed, then the GW can regift...but until how many times? If the second Seer, for example, is also killed or ungifted, what then? Can the GW gift someone until he's dead?
11. I remember that the last game there were a couple of Seer dreams lost and the Hunter failed to make a choice because (I'm not sure if this goes for all those cases) they wanted to discuss their options with the GW but ran out of time. Is extending one phase an option? Or will they be allowed to converse Day and Night?
12. I think there was a Hunter complication last game, and I'm not sure if that has already been addressed.
I think I'll go and do something about this headache. I'm sorry if I also gave you one - I'm not feeling most coherent.