[Legate of Amon Lanc]

I am back! Well, nothing much different for me to say. Nog seems to me that he is playing wolfy-safe this time, really. Like, bringing suspicion against someone, then being a little reserved when he thinks he should calm down and let the waters calm a little, like in this case with Lommy:

Originally Posted by Nogrod

And after all this I think I have some reasons to believe you're more innocent than not (the way you reacted felt quite genuine) which I didn't have yesterDay. Sadly I can't say the same of Legate as his reactions to the affair felt more sinister. But without further points on him I would not like to vote for him at least yet.

Then I don't like the things he bases his suspicions on - they are too "simple" for Nog! He, from my point of view gives too much weight in his cases to things like Lommy saying "Poor Lhuna" or what it was, or this:

Originally Posted by Nog

So look at this quote from Nerwen after she defends her vote on Lhuna being forced to make it early: !!!

These are the simplest things one catches a wolf on. But surely we know well that even normal people may say things like that and it's not necessary to always build case on that. Or at least say "Yes, but also..." And I would expect Nog at least to come to this with more "critical thinking", eh? Unless he has interest to not include it but build suspicion against those people among others.

Originally Posted by Nog

Also Lommy had a nice find from Gwath:

And this could be a wolf catching upon a suspicion that can be built, and which even others may follow...

Originally Posted by Nog

Also I still think Volo's self-vote was more suspicious than not.

Not sure why. I also have to check what you said about his self-vote yesterday... if you did anything... because I think there's nothing odd on that.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

A point of semantics... I guess I was thinking that if wolves indeed contributed to her death they "killed" her, but if it bothers you I'll amend it to "lynched".

Well yes, but it was not just about the word you used, of course it's clear you meant lynched (although it's odd), however you talked even the way that it looked like you took the lynch of Lhuna as some planned event, like a kill, indeed. I don't know what to make of it at all, but I simply find that odd.

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Also, Legate should stop that behaviour instantly! Whatever I say about him, he posts right after me and changes my opinion.

Oh, sorry. That's not intentional But at least it keeps your mind thinking it over, doesn't it?

EDIT: x-ed just a little... since Mith or what was it, before Lommy now...