The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Werewolf XLIV: In the House of Tom Bombadil

Rikae · 03-03-2008, 12:09 AM

I'm going to bed now, it's after midnight. I only got my paper about 1/3 finished (wonder why

) so I may not have much time to post here tomorrow.
At the very least, I'll give my opinions as things stand at the moment:
Nogrod - See above.
Nerwen - One I really should analyze before I come to any conclusions. She's cast a lot of really strangely-founded suspicions around, at any rate. She seems a bit too determined to lynch Volo.
Menel - He's also made odd accusations. He was quick to jump on Lommy for banter on Day 1, and quick to jump on Nogrod's analysis of Nerwen without apparent reason. If he's a wolf, I expect Nerwen isn't.
Durelin - Actually, in looking over her past posts, I find myself wondering whether I don't partly percieve her as wolfish because of her sarcasm, which is, if I recall rightly, normal. I still find her reaction to Mac's "confession" (as well as her Day 1 words about him "jumping" on Lommy) fishy.
Mith - I'm inclined to think that she's a more honest person than I am, and making the declaration of innocence she did, as a wolf, would be too low and dishonest a tactic even for me. If she does turn out a wolf, I'll never trust her again, but for now I think she's innocent. (By the way, for what it's worth, as God is my witness -- I am an ordo.)
Lommy -- Like I said, I got the feeling she was pushing Nogrod a bit too much toDay, and I didn't like the way she simultaneously told us not to consider it. Still, since Nogrod looks suspicious too... and partly because of his repeated declarations of Lommy's innocence... hm. I think at least one of the two is most likely a wolf, at any rate.
Volo -- Well, he's Volo. As I said, 50/50.

I don't know what to do -- I think everyone but Mith is suspicious, to some degree. Perhaps it would be useful to analyze who is, and is not, likely to be a wolf with who else, but I don't have the time, myself. I hope someone else does.

*sigh*

Does anyone think Nogrod and Menel might be wolves together?

03-03-2008, 12:09 AM	#446
Rikae Mellifluous Maia Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: A glade open to the stars, deep in Nan Elmoth Posts: 3,489	I'm going to bed now, it's after midnight. I only got my paper about 1/3 finished (wonder why ) so I may not have much time to post here tomorrow. At the very least, I'll give my opinions as things stand at the moment: Nogrod - See above. Nerwen - One I really should analyze before I come to any conclusions. She's cast a lot of really strangely-founded suspicions around, at any rate. She seems a bit too determined to lynch Volo. Menel - He's also made odd accusations. He was quick to jump on Lommy for banter on Day 1, and quick to jump on Nogrod's analysis of Nerwen without apparent reason. If he's a wolf, I expect Nerwen isn't. Durelin - Actually, in looking over her past posts, I find myself wondering whether I don't partly percieve her as wolfish because of her sarcasm, which is, if I recall rightly, normal. I still find her reaction to Mac's "confession" (as well as her Day 1 words about him "jumping" on Lommy) fishy. Mith - I'm inclined to think that she's a more honest person than I am, and making the declaration of innocence she did, as a wolf, would be too low and dishonest a tactic even for me. If she does turn out a wolf, I'll never trust her again, but for now I think she's innocent. (By the way, for what it's worth, as God is my witness -- I am an ordo.) Lommy -- Like I said, I got the feeling she was pushing Nogrod a bit too much toDay, and I didn't like the way she simultaneously told us not to consider it. Still, since Nogrod looks suspicious too... and partly because of his repeated declarations of Lommy's innocence... hm. I think at least one of the two is most likely a wolf, at any rate. Volo -- Well, he's Volo. As I said, 50/50. I don't know what to do -- I think everyone but Mith is suspicious, to some degree. Perhaps it would be useful to analyze who is, and is not, likely to be a wolf with who else, but I don't have the time, myself. I hope someone else does. sigh Does anyone think Nogrod and Menel might be wolves together?