[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Oh, and about Shasta? I may be reading into it too much, but I still think Menel's sudden reduction in suspicion of him indicates a dream. Or am I semi-alone in this theory? If so, does anyone else have an explanation for it?

I said already yesterDay that I think so. On the other hand, Nogrod proposed other theory, and it does not seem totally impossible either. Cf. also below.

Originally Posted by McCaber

Gwath admits he looks suspicious, but is he just trying to divert attention by bringing it up himself? I do really want to hear more about his reasoning.

Well, yes - I must say Gwath's behavior can be called "overall pre-emptive", and lately I started to think whether he was not staging up things as they suit him and therefore avoid suspicion. However, my opinion earlier was that it's just his behavior and I don't want to come with groundbreaking new suspicions when the numbers are so low, as it was pointed out here, and I have stronger suspicions on other people.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Sally, you cannot be serious. The village was in desperate straits last Night.

If we had lynched another ordo, today there would three wolves to four innocents. All it would take is one of them to fall for Rikae's "Voice of Saruman" act or her crocodile tears or whatever method she chose to employ.

We simply could not afford to pass up a near-certainty like Rikae.

That's what I thought. Apparently, she was able to talk at least one person that Menel did not dream of her, and as you see, even this almost saved her. If Nerwen is innocent, then as she said, toDay could have easily been out last Day.

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Nerwen, I'd like to point out that my vote for you was just what I said it was, putting another option on the table just in case. I've been dead early recently, but I've followed the recent games, and I've seen people who were unhappy about lynching people, but voted them anyway because there wasn't enough time to get enough votes on someone else; i.e. another option. That's all.

Well, that sounds rather genuine. Combined with the thing that Menel might have dreamt of Shasta, I am inclined to look better at him.

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Come on people, use simple logic. Rikae was an obvious wolf. With her gone, yes, our numbers are better, and I understand that, so I was fine with either Rikae or Nerwen dying yesterday, because it would be so stinking simple to kill her toDay. She was an obvious wolf, and I assumed everyone saw that. So why not try a questionable wolf? Obviously, there was the risk of killing an ordo, but Nerwen's been looking pretty furry, so I thought it was worth the risk in this case, this one case. Rikae would have been easily killed today, at least in my opinion, as she was a blatantly obvious wolf. And I personally wanted to be able to see what could be made of Nerwen's reactions with others in the game. I believe it could help us find the other wolf, or wolves on the off-chance that she is not a wolf herself. Hence while my vote may seem stupid as Nerwen strongly implies, it was actually pretty well considered.

This, on the other hand, I still don't like and not even know whether I should believe it. I think it's more likely that Sally is simply the Wolf, for reasons stated above, and that yesterDay was an attempt to save a wolf proven by Seer's dream - and it even almost worked.

All right - well, a little quieter around here, but not that bad. I'll be around. As I said, I am most likely to vote Sally toDay, but plenty time still.

And btw, where is Nogrod?

edit: x-ed with some Gwaths and Nerwen