Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
That must mean Menel was the Seer....
I suppose now one must wonder just why he was so adamantly against Rikae.
|
Indeed, it's quite obvious he was the Seer. And yes, that's a question one has to ask.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gwathagor
I suppose it's possible that Menel had dreamed about Rikae? Should we assume that he was right about all those he accused?
|
Well, surely not about all those he accused as YesterDay, he went after
Mac and
Rikae quite continuously, but now we know
Mac was innocent. However, I find it quite improbable that his going after
Rikae would be totally baseless. At least personally I believe that if he had dreamt of any Wolf, he would have voted him, and since he did not vote for anyone but
Rikae, I am quite inclined to believe that he dreamt of her and found her a Wolf.
I will go quickly through his posts, I now have the chance to compare them in the new light with the analysis I was preparing yesterDay; it may come handy as some quick reference. Although
Menel can't be of any active help anymore, I think we should try to find if we don't find any hints from him about whom he could have dreamed. He had two Nights to dream (before Day 1 and before Day 2) before he was killed. Also, there would be a good question as to why he was killed - did the Wolves reveal him, or was it just pure luck and they were following some other scheme? I think such things may be of a lot help.
Will be back soon.
edit: x-ed with Rikae