Thread: Lazy Nazgul
View Single Post
Old 01-29-2008, 01:42 PM   #47
Gordis
Shade of Carn Dūm
 
Gordis's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Minas Morgul
Posts: 431
Gordis is a guest of Tom Bombadil.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Narcolindo View Post
It could touch souls and minds. I think the whole idea of the Nazgūl sensing the Ring's presence is because of the magnitude of its presence in the spiritual realm. Of course if the Ring wants to go back to its master, but is bound to the spiritual realm in a physical object, it might try and contact its master's servants through the same realm.
"To touch souls and minds" - That's what I call "emitting the signal". No, I didn't mean supersonic beeps, I meant osanwe contact. So, I don't see any contradiction in our ideas.
But maybe you think that the Ring tried to touch souls and minds - to make manifest its presence intermittently? It is theoretically possible, but then some cases are hard to explain. For instance how come Gandalf the Maia, wielder of one of the Three failed to recognize this presence?

Quote:
We find in the Reader's Companion that the Dūnedain sent for him because he was the only one who successfully might resist the Nazgūl.
I am not aware of this, though I have read the RC. Can you post the quote, please?

And, as Legate, I don't think Khamul was not paying attention. He should have had - after all, he was chosen to go to Hobbitton because of his sensitivity to the Ring.

Quote:
Legate: More likely now, I would presume that someone else led the assaults on Lórien (remember there wasn't only one!) and that Khamul, or another Nazgul for that matter, would carry messages about the war to Mordor. That's a much better way of using the (Winged) Nazgul's abilities.
The best way was to send him lead the assault and when it failed, make him come to report about it in person.

Quote:
Legate: So: Ulmo's power, yes, but not "direct", rather some "immanent" power.
Agreed.
Gordis is offline   Reply With Quote