Quote:
Originally Posted by Gordis
Another proof is that being the Second to the WK, Khamul didn't take command after the Black Captain was slain, but Gothmog did (who I always thought to be another nazgul).
|
Me not
Anyway, that's a matter of opinion; but I think for the purposes of this we cannot take it as proof for Khamul's absence, as we can't say for sure what Gothmog was. Btw I thought if you have something to say on this subject, there were several threads concerning Gothmog back then, I remember for example
this one (and I believe there's a link to another one in it).
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Gordis
On March 15 3019, two nazgul (Khamul + another) must have been in Dol-Guldur, as exactly on the same day both Lorien and Thranduil were attacked. Perhaps, even three nazgul were dispatched North, as there were 3 goals: Lorien, Thranduil and Dale-Erebor.
|
Hm, but where do you take support for the presupposition that the nazgul were leading any of these battles? For example concerning myself, this is the first time I encountered such an idea, before it did not even cross my mind. And I mean evidence, not just your own theory.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Gordis
And their training area was above the Dead Marches. It is much nicer to plummet down onto the slime of the Marches instead of the hard rocks of Gorgoroth.  |
Well, not sure... thinking about their aversion to water, maybe the hard rocks would've been preferable...