I might have to floodpost a little here as I don't have an enormous amount of time. I will also warn that I will have to vote early, only but a couple of hours though. I think then that it's a good idea to look at what happened on the other days:
Day 1: Legate, Menel and Valier
Now, I consider Legate innocent and I believe Menel with his revelation so I guess I would have to consider Valier suspicious here. And indeed there were some odd things in her behaviour:
Quote:
|
Ok let's say I was a wolf (which I'm not, seriously).
|
There is no need for that validation, why put it unless you have something to hide.
Also there's quite a sudden switch in opinion, as she suspected Menel throughout most of the Day yet finally voted for Legate. I'm aware that it was partly to save her own skin but I still think it's odd.
I am wary about this though, as it is highly possible that Legate was in fact a wolf. Just because I think he is innocent doesn't mean I can discount him.
Day 2: McCaber, Naria and Roa
This was an odd Day. I really don't like that McCaber failed to vote. He spent the whole time Roa was there being suspicious of Naria and then suddenly he isn't even there to vote? Naria was very, very jumpy. She said there was no way to get herself out of a lynch but that's not true, if she had been calm and managed to convince McCaber of Roa's guilt. But I just don't know where to assign roles here. Roa's 'oh woe is me' talk could have been equally innocent or guilty. Naria's jumpiness could equally be a sign of a scared wolf or a frustrated innocent. And McCaber. Well of the three I have the most suspicion of him simply for failing to vote, but there can so often be other reasons. I just can't make up my mind about this Day.
Day 3: Agan, Ka, Shasta
This Day makes sense. Shasta barely spoke and the other two voted for someone who didn't make much of an effort rather than someone who did. Doesn't mean though that they were right. It would be odd for a wolf to be the quiet one when they had seen in the previous Day that not being around was likely to mean you got voted for. Which suggests to me that Ka or Agan is our wolf.
Ka made an odd comment about looking hard at Agan because she made good posts, it sounded like she was going to be suspicious of her despite being helpful. In addition, Agan looks pretty innocent to me and came up with some good points about Lommy. So here I would have Ka as the wolf.
Day 4: Lommy, Might and Nog
I've discussed this. At the moment I have Lommy as the wolf here.
Day 5: sally, Kath and Gil
With no Gil we had little choice. I saw nothing suspicious in Sally, I don't think she saw anything suspicious in me. Still, with nothing from Gil it's impossible to know whether he was the wolf or not. Another Day where I can't decide anything.
Day 6: Zali, Brinn, Groin
Brinn said quite a lot and although I disagree with quite a chunk of it, it was at least well reasoned. Same goes for Zali actually. From the posts I wonder if toDay was the Day where a wolf was lynched. Groin's comments were very, very odd with some flip-flopping and some apparent misunderstandings. I would have pegged him as the wolf in that trio.
Day 7: Greenie, Izzy, Rikae
Then again, this looks like a Day where a wolf was lynched. Greenie saying that Izzy looked more suspicious than Rikae yet then suddenly turning round and trying to lynch Rik the second she voted for her is suspicious.
So my wolf list stands as:
Lommy
Valier
MCaber
Ka
I think in that order too. But I still don't want to lynch Lommy toDay. Yet I'm not sure who else to vote for. I'm going to hang around for a little while, watch the posting and try to make my mind up.