[Roa_Aoife]

Please correct me if I’ve misinterpreted something.

McCaber Analysis- Initial

1st – Doesn’t see a reason to throw out suspicions so early in the day, says Nogrod’s vocalness could work against him, as Valier and Groin’s quietness could work against them, but currently suspects Ka and Legate, for monologues and dice rolls, says we shouldn’t put much stock in this

Right off the bat I find it odd that he says he doesn’t see a reason to suspect people, and then lays out his suspicions of people. Then there’s the contradiction of Nogrod’s loudness being a tool along with Valier and Groin’s quietness. The wording is odd, but I can’t figure out why.

2nd – Thanks Menel for saying that loud wolves are more dangerous than quiet wolves, says he doesn’t like to share every thought that crosses his mind.

Is he saying this because he’s new and didn’t know what to do? Or is it because he’s a wolf and was hoping someone else would point away from his general direction? Also, people who keep ideas and thoughts to themselves don’t help the village- they hinder it. If you think something is suspicious, point it out for the rest of us. Stir discussion so that we have something to talk about, and so we can catch the wolves in their lies. Maybe not every single thought is necessary, but more than one or two would be better.

And… that’s it. McCaber, why didn’t you return? You threw out some admittedly poor suspicions, complained about people picking on the quiet ones, and then disappeared.


Naria Analysis- Initial

1st – Says she forgot we could speak on that day, nothing suspicious jumps out at her, chatter is just going in circles, says she’s really unable to make long or numerous posts, will attempt further comment

Okay, I almost didn’t realize we could speak on Day 0.0, so I can believe that Naria forgot. Other than that, this post is really bland. Nothing is suspicious, there’s nothing to argue against, and she’s bad at being talkative. And that’s all from Naria. Wher did you go? Did you form any suspicions? Why didn’t you make further comment?

With only this, McCaber has more wolfish behavior than Naria, but that’s only because Naria’s one post said little to nothing. It feels almost un fair to vote for him just because Naria didn’t really say anything wolfish, or really, anything at all. What a dilemma….

Edit: Cross-posted. Glad to see everyone's here. *grin* I'm looking forward to it too, Naria.