|
What I can't see is how you can have the charm (or tweeness) of the beginning of TH, the 'humourous' encounter with the Trolls & the chasing around after the spiders & combine that with the hack & slash action of LotR. Somebody is going to be disappointed. Tolkien couldn't bring LotR into line with the mood & style of LotR so I doubt Jackson et al can.
Another problem will be in expectations - fans of the LotR movies want Aragorn & Legolas doing their 'tricks', wheras, if the movies are at all faithful to the book, what they'll get is a sweet little Bilbo & a troop of comical Dwarves.
I simply can't see a typical movie goer (17 year old male apparently) sitting through two plus hours of that before they get to see a Dragon & a big battle. So, what we'll probably see is a battle in the mountain cave a la the Mines of Moria sequence, a Mirkwood encounter with multiple 'Shelobs' & some vicious combat with the Trolls - all of which will take the Hobbit movie far from its origins. And let's face it, when Jackson & co take off on their own & leave Tolkien behind they tend to mess up big time - which, let's face it, doesn't bode well for the sequel.
|