Quote:
Originally Posted by obloquy
Have you even read the Silmarillion?
|
Yes, I have, and though I must admit that Kuthien did some pretty amazing things, I think Cirdan beats her in that area. (I would give an example, but I haven't got much time now, maybe later)
Quote:
Originally Posted by obloquy
Also, I'm curious: why would you say that Elwe is an Elda only because of "strange circumstances"?
|
Because though he did "behold the light" he is also of the Sindar (If Sindar does not count as Eldar). He is both an Elda and a Sinda. He refused to go to Valinor, so he is of the Úmanyar as well (I think, correct me if I am wrong, but I know he is a Sinda)