[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Is there still confusion over the narratives? I just saw the Night 4 narrative now, because it had been added.

Macalaure was the cursed villager.

Night 2: Shasta killed.

Night 3: Ranger protected Macalaure (know this by process of elimation -- see below)

Night 4: Macalaure attacked and turned (see narrative).

Night 5: Boromir killed.

This explains all ambiguities. Boromir protected Macalaure on Night 3; then someone else on Night 4, possibly Farael; but the wolves couldn't be sure and killed Boromir instead.

If the cursed was turned on Night 4 (which we do, because of the narrative) then Mac had to be innocent on Night 3 (because of the successful Ranger protection).