Quote:
Originally Posted by Aganzir
Ok. Another thing. Nogrod's post #164 and Rikae. Why did Noggie start suspecting her then? It could be a last-minute case against a fellow wolf. It could be a last-minute case against an innocent that is supposed to look like a case against a fellow-wolf. A bluff, double-bluff, triple-bluff?
I thought this would be good to bring forward. I don't suspect Rikae at the moment, but it always means something if a wolf makes a case against someone when it's clearly too late to lynch him/her anymore.
For example, maybe the wolf wants us to think it was a case against a fellow so that we lynch a player who is dangerous for the pack... |
I have thought myself that the attack on Rikae probably means
something, but I don't think there's any point worrying about it yet.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim
(quoting Shasta) "Nogrod's first post was, strangely, shorter than mine. What does this say about him?
-Nogrod is hiding "off the radar". He's obviously a wolf.
-Nogrod is too busy to pay much attention to this game. A perfect cover for a wolf.
-Nogrod is letting us come to our own conclusions, without exerting too much influence. Waiting for the right moment to make an opportune push... much like a wolf might do.
I think we have our answer here, don't you?
The herbs have made me loopy, the herbs have made me loopy.... "
|
I think that's pretty convincing. And it's only logical that they thought he was a gifted– I can't think of any other reason why he was killed.
Now, about
Eomer himself: my current feeling is that his vote to save
Nogrod was quite innocent. I think a wolf would have tried to cover himself more (firstly, by not
saying he was trying to save a fellow wolf).
Then there's
Valier: I think it would be nice if she gave
actual reasons for her vote, as opposed to muttering vaguely about "circumstances".
I assume, though, that she's falling in with
Mac's theories on
Aganzir– which sound very, very forced to me. I mean, it's more than likely that there was at least one wolf among the
Nogrod voters, but I don't think it was her.
EDIT: X'd with
Kath and
Mac.