Mr. Hicklin - could you please answer my previous request to you first and then we can move on? First things first.
Again, you stated
Quote:
|
The issue is the rather astonishing claim that all the First and Second age material Tolkien ever wrote is somehow 'incorporated by reference' into the Appendices.
|
And I asked you.....Could be please cite the quote where anyone made that "rather astonishing claim"? And I would like the exact quote not some rehash, a retelling , a paraphrasing, a translation, an "its the same thing as...", or "it sounded like to me that ...".
Please be good enough to cover that ground before we move on. Thank you.