The loss of Glorfindel is a forgivable twist, as far as I am concerned, but that doesn't mean I think it was ok. But if I was going to kill PJ it wouldn't be for that.
Don't worry, I'm really not in the least violent.
As you can probably see, I don't really like Arwen. In fact, while watching TTT with family we
always fast foward almost every scene with her in it. So you could say, I am uncommonly biased, not only liking Glorfindel, but disliking the movie Arwen.