Quote:
Originally Posted by Raynor
Well, Fingolfin is described as the "strongest, the most steadfast, and the most valiant". These two statements seem to go head to head, unless Tolkien was referring to Feanor's fire, when talking about his strength - and thus considering a spiritual potence, which might or might not translate into physical/combative aptitude, depending on how hot-headed he was at the moment. So, it may be that the answer is Feanor, if he keeps his cool, otherwise it's Fingolfin.
|
I was in the process of writing something similar, and i totally agree.
I think Feanor is perhaps not viewed as a "warrior" because of the fact that he died, simple as. I think that if he had killed one of the Balrogs and then proceeded to die, it would be completely different. He dies quite early in the story, therefore we don't manage to see a transformation or adaptation of the character. All we know is that it took several Balrogs to stay him... more than most people can take on - but it's only speculation about how he would have fared in the wars, being that he wasn't mentioned much in relation to battle previously.. the kinslaying of the Teleri i think was the bit just before.
But undoubtedley Feanor has to be in the Top Ten of "conventional" warriors
- i believe.
However, on sheer favouritism, i have to go with Fingolfin
Though the thought of a Feanor Vs Morgoth would have been absolutely fantastic. Place your bets now!