How about an Elrond/Faramir dilemma for you then, Mithalwen? :P
I think my choice would be the Faramir Vs Boromir face-off. T'would be
no contest in terms of the films, but as for the books...flip...that's just too tough to answer....
I just wonder how many guys would prefer Arwen (or Xenarwen to give her the proper name as this is the film I am talking about now) if she had been played by say.......Keira Knightley? She seems so much more suited to Xenarwen than the lovely placid Liv.