[the guy who be short]

(Guy)
So yes, the Rikae thing went badly. On the plus side we've left no trail. On the minus side, the two captains now know that Rikae is an innocent. This knowledge may help us to find them. If we have a good suspicion, then killing one of them would be excellent. If not, I suppose we could go for Rikae again, although I'd prefer not to, as she thinks me innocent. It's a possiblity, of course, that she is one of the captains...

I get the feeling that at least one, possibly both, of Nogrod and Mac are gifted. Killing Nogrod would, I feel, make people lynch me - if we keep him alive long enough, people get suspicious! And Mac thinks us both innocent, good to keep around.

Therefore, while I have not yet checked for clues about who is suspicious, my two top choices at the moment are Rikae and Brinn. Reasons:

1) The captains know Rikae is innocent. Everybody trusts her. Minuses are that she is slightly suspicious of Nogrod (keeping her could help his eventual lynching) and that she doesnt suspect me. If we don't kill her, we really must kill a captain, because having two of the villagers know the innocence of 3 of the villagers is very bad for us.

2) Brinn. If I feel that she may be a captain, I'd really LOVE to lynch her. She really has no suspects except me. Now that xyzzy, who I campaigned to get lynched, has been proved to be innocent, we could kill her off and I could claim it's a set-up. I will have to check what everybody has said and see how gifted she feels...

But our main priority is to get a captain. Perhaps Mac (if analysis shows him to be captainy) after all?

See Mac? We were onto you...

(Lhuna)
I'm not really keen on going after Rikae toNight. Sure, she scares me a bit, because I think she suspects me even just a little, but we've better options.

Of all the Outlaws, Mac's the one standing out to me most as a possible Beleg.

Nogrod is playing too boldly, I think, to be gifted. But I won't put it past him to deceive the wolves in this way. If we kill him, then the Outlaws will think they really have desperate and amateur wolves among them, as Nogrod suggested. That could probably keep them off our trail. The same could be said of Mac, I suppose, to a bit lesser degree.

As for Brinn...are you sure you can manage to throw off suspicion if she is killed? But I'm not worried about her yet. She hasn't contributed much, and could be up for lynching.

Ah, but now that I think about Rikae, I think you have a point that it would be ill for us if we let her live with the Captains knowing her innocent! But wait...isn't that just the same thing as with the Seer? What matters is that the Captains don't beat us to revealing her innocence - or worse, our lycanthropy.

But I guess it's safe if one of us gets revealed, because I think we've been doing a good job hiding that we're working together.

So my choices are Nogrod and Mac. Mac then? I can't be here long, so if you don't catch me online, I'll leave the final decision to you. Then we're even.

So you see, if we had killed that night, it would probably have been Mac, and then things would have gone much better... As it happened, I had difficulties getting onto the internet again due to my sister occupying the computer. This meant I didn't get Lhuna's PM until too late and so nothing happened. Alack.