[the guy who be short]

(Lhuna)
So for our kill, do we try to hunt for Turin or Beleg, or kill the one we think is the most dangerous player? The latter would naturally mean Nogrod, but I'm not sure it's a good idea to kill him this early. He expressed a bit of trust in me, so I guess it could serve as a bit of a cover, but it could also backfire. Also, he voted for you. I say we leave him alive for now.

Mac was under quite heavy suspicion yesterDay, and if we can push it further tomorrow we don't need to worry about him.

The person I most feel like killing toNight is Rikae. I don't know why, but there you go. I've never played with Isabellkya or xyzzy so I don't know if they are formidable foes.

Those are my thoughts for now. I'll try to read the thread more closely tonight to see if some other suitable victim will jump out at me.

(Guy)
I think it will be difficult to go after the gifteds today, so let us wait until one of them dies accidentally - by our hand, or by the village's. This means going after somebody else...

I'm not sure about Noggy. I'd quite like to see if I can get him killed - his stance on killing xyzzy is bizarre! He is also completely unpredictable so hopefully he'll be looking elsewhere tomorrow.

Brinn is a worry to me, but killing her is too dangerous.

Mac was not actually under too much suspicion. He also said he'd look at me tomorrow. I think maybe it would be better to keep him around though - I think I will eventually be lynched, and in that case, his vote today, plus his neutrality towards me, could be interpreted as wolvish. Basically, when I die, I'd like him to be lynched next day.

What I would actually quite like is to kill somebody random and unsuspecting. Rikae is a good choice, but I think Isabellkya would be even more random and confuse everybody. It might even lead them to think the wolves feel they are under no pressure, and so start looking at new people (i.e. not me!).

Either of these would make me happy, it's up to you.

(Lhuna)
Ah, my dear STAWB, how could you do this to me? My choices usually go amiss! But at least you narrowed down the list to two, and agreed with my choice. Rikae or Isabellkya, then?

I don't feel comfortable killing someone who is yet to speak. And there's the possibility that Izzy isn't gifted; otherwise it would have been hard for her to miss the Day's discussions. It's possible she had RL reasons, though.

But if you speak of random and unsuspecting kills, what better choice than Gil-galad? Seriously, though, I'm going with Rikae, much though I would like her in the game longer. I'm unable to foresee any danger in that move right now, maybe there's none.

++RIKAE

So there you go. Rikae was our first mistake. I'd have preferred Izzy as Brinn guessed. This was to be the source of much future night-time worrying for me.