Love you too morm.
Aganzir - defends Fea. Had Menel down as innocent but with it being so early in the game those without extra knowledge couldn't have known he was a wolf. But then, she got xyzzy and Rune down as innocents correctly too. Chance or something more? Actually I think it is just chance. Aganzir is a fine werewolf player from what I've seen of her and I don't think that if she is a wolf she'd give such a 'he's innocent' statement about Menel. Thinks Shasta and Volo are the ones that look most suspicious and could vote for the former.
Guy - feels Noggie, Boro and Rune are innocent all with some reasoning behind it. I may disagree with it but it makes him look innocent.
Lommy - says she can't really find anyone to suspect bar xyzzy and Boro, and the cases against those two aren't good. Does no one else feel that she's a bit off? I usually find that she feels very innocent, admittedly even when she is a wolf, so this seems odd to me.
Mith - does agree that loud players are more useful than quiet ones, but says it's too early to really be worrying about it. Says she was mentioning me rather than suspecting me though I might still be evil, but it's the hasty votes that merit the most attention. She was the one that noted the possible meaning within Sauce's narration, picking out some pretty interesting and possible points.
Volo - argues against the voting for the unhelpful or quiet players. Odd statement about Lommy always voting xyzzy with no reason when she had just avoided doing that before turning that on it's head and saying that actually he does think xyzzy is suspicious. It isn't the flip flop that I don't like but rather the comment to Lommy. She had specifically avoided voting xyzzy for no reason so why say it? Decides he won't vote Nogrod because when he looks guilty he's generally innocent. Well, he said he was going to use odd logic. Which apparently includes defending me. I don't think Volo has ever been on my side before! Says Rikae feels like wolf-Rikae so he won't vote her either. This is actually quite irritating this new tactic, mostly because he isn't giving any reasons for his suspicions. Uses his mad logic to think that Rikae and guy are the ones that seem suspicious, but says he doesn't want to vote for guy. Then votes guy. Interesting flip flop, perhaps he's taking lessons from Lommy. I hope Volo starts to put some more understandable logic in soon, I'm having trouble following him.
Legate - says only later in the game will he advocate killing the quiet ones but does mention that Izzie turned up and then disappeared again which he finds irresponsible. It's an odd word to use but then Legate is prone to using long words. Thinks xyzzy innocent but finds Noggie, Lommy and Menel suspicious. Looks pretty innocent to me so far. Weird post where he first says that he thinks lynching the quiet ones early is a good idea, but then turns around completely and says actually no it isn't. This feels more like a train of thought post to me, where as he was writing he changed his mind. Only thing is that it started off as a defense against guy saying he was in fact arguing against Rune when previously he'd said he was agreeing with him. And then he says why not lynch morm, totally getting the wrong stick of guy's argument (at least the way I see it). Not sure if this is confused innocent or twisting wolf.
Rikae - defends herself against my earlier suspicion pretty calmly, and then adds on her own suspicion of me. In fairness it's probably merited since my suspicion of her was based on a readthrough that had only taken tone into account not content. Says xyzzy could be worth voting for but doesn't really seem to think he's suspicious which is a bit odd.
Boro - is somewhat suspicious of Mith for mentioning that the first poster has been found to be wolvish in the past. There was once a summary looking at that which I think found that the first poster could be pretty much anything, so Boro might actually have something there. I always find it odd when Mith uses statistical type arguments to support what she's saying, it doesn't feel like something she'd do. Still, the last time I said that she ended up being the Seer or something, so I'll let it go. Says to let everyone do their own thing as if we come up with a plan it will give the wolves an advantage since they'll know what we're doing. This is a good point. Plans are only ever useful if you have known innocents and Gifted's to ensure the wolves can't use it to their own ends, and hopefully we won't have either for a while yet, so long as we don't go and force a Gifted to reveal so early.
Menel - voted xyzzy.
Fea - makes a lot of lists. I never can get a read on her. Votes xyzzy because she has no one better to vote for, suggesting that her list where she put Mith and morm as 'blood-stained' wasn't really based on anything.
Rune - says he won't vote Menel as he often does and finds him innocent, but that he's less worried about suspecting Boro because he turns out to be guilty more often. Then votes Durelin for no real reason. The narration seems to suggest Rune was attacked by the wolves, and really it does make sense. He'd not said much, mostly commenting on the quiet/loud debate and making non-commital comments about people. No trail.
Guy - votes Durelin after previously using his 'random number generator' to end up with her name and then said he was doing it in order to lynch the quiet ones. Coming up with two reasons just to randomly lynch someone seems odd to me.
Ok I'm being called off to eat dinner now and then I believe we have a film to watch. I've got to post 90 now and I may finish this when I get back but to be honest
I'm getting bored of it so I can't imagine how dull everyone else is finding it. I'll probably just try and organise my thoughts as to what I think of who. Should be back around 10.