The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

Aganzir · 06-01-2007, 05:50 AM

Kath: I know I had been thinking about the number of the wolves myself, too (probably everyone has); but then asking it would make a nice cover for a wolf, and that's what I thought when I read Kath's first post.

xyzzy: There's not much to go on, but I don't consider him suspicious just because of his "suspicion" on Kath.

Shasta: He has said nothing that should have made me worry about him, but I get a bad feeling of his posts.

Menel: I agree with him about forcing the wolves to talk. But lynching ye unhelpfulle - I don't know. I see the logic, but I don't know if it's wise to force the wolves to be helpful, because they won't actually help us - on the contrary, a wolf making analyses etc. is far from useful; they twist everything and mislead us, and when the wolf is dead, what can one make out of the analysis?
Anyway I think he's probably innocent.

Rune: He speaks sense, and not things I think a wolf would say.

Nogrod: At the moment I feel quite safe about him (though I still think I would never catch a wolf-Nogrod). His suggestion of lynching the quiet ones is good, I think, and as he's been reasonable and vocal, I'm inclined to consider him innocent.

Rikae: It's hard to say anything about her.

Isabellkya: Not much to go on, but I fail to see any "wolf hints".

Boro: I've no idea, but I don't think lynching him toDay would be a good thing to do. He's just so neutral.

Durelin: Amusing, but not much to say. I don't know what I should think of her vote.

Sixth: Neutral.

Lommy: Innocentish.

tgwbs: I've never played with him, and don't know his style. There's something slightly suspicious in him, but I don't know if it's just his style, so I probably won't vote for him toDay.

Mith: I will probably send this before she's managed to say anything more.

Possibly innocent:
Menel
Rune
Nogrod
Lommy

Possibly guilty:
Kath
Shasta
tgwbs

No idea:
xyzzy
Rikae
Isabellkya
Boro
Durelin
Sixth
Mith

Have not spoken yet:
Mormegil
Gil-Galad
Volo
Legate
Fea

I have no idea who to vote yet (luckily there's still plenty of time left). I don't think anyone is that suspicious. I guess I'll vote someone silent.

edit: xed since Mith's second post.

06-01-2007, 05:50 AM	#3
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	I might as well do something useful Kath: I know I had been thinking about the number of the wolves myself, too (probably everyone has); but then asking it would make a nice cover for a wolf, and that's what I thought when I read Kath's first post. xyzzy: There's not much to go on, but I don't consider him suspicious just because of his "suspicion" on Kath. Shasta: He has said nothing that should have made me worry about him, but I get a bad feeling of his posts. Menel: I agree with him about forcing the wolves to talk. But lynching ye unhelpfulle - I don't know. I see the logic, but I don't know if it's wise to force the wolves to be helpful, because they won't actually help us - on the contrary, a wolf making analyses etc. is far from useful; they twist everything and mislead us, and when the wolf is dead, what can one make out of the analysis? Anyway I think he's probably innocent. Rune: He speaks sense, and not things I think a wolf would say. Nogrod: At the moment I feel quite safe about him (though I still think I would never catch a wolf-Nogrod). His suggestion of lynching the quiet ones is good, I think, and as he's been reasonable and vocal, I'm inclined to consider him innocent. Rikae: It's hard to say anything about her. Isabellkya: Not much to go on, but I fail to see any "wolf hints". Boro: I've no idea, but I don't think lynching him toDay would be a good thing to do. He's just so neutral. Durelin: Amusing, but not much to say. I don't know what I should think of her vote. Sixth: Neutral. Lommy: Innocentish. tgwbs: I've never played with him, and don't know his style. There's something slightly suspicious in him, but I don't know if it's just his style, so I probably won't vote for him toDay. Mith: I will probably send this before she's managed to say anything more. Possibly innocent: Menel Rune Nogrod Lommy Possibly guilty: Kath Shasta tgwbs No idea: xyzzy Rikae Isabellkya Boro Durelin Sixth Mith Have not spoken yet: Mormegil Gil-Galad Volo Legate Fea I have no idea who to vote yet (luckily there's still plenty of time left). I don't think anyone is that suspicious. I guess I'll vote someone silent. edit: xed since Mith's second post. __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.