Quote:
Back to Aragorn. I think Aragorn's words imply that he entered through the eastern gate and then again left through the same gate. He could, as well, have come through and open the Western gate by just pushing it (as Gandalf says), but
a) he says "I passed once the Dimrill Gate", which does not seem like he passed through Moria, but just the gate (might be he even just walked three steps in, then decided that it's not much nice and left),
b) he says "I also came out again", which not only does not say that he must've left through the other gate, but may as well sound like he came out through the same entrance.
And c), mainly, Aragorn does not seem to know at all, how to navigate Moria. Gandalf himself explains gaps in his knowledge by it being long ago since he went there, and that he was going from east to west, not from west to east, like Fellowship now went. But, while Gandalf at least tries to lead the Fellowship, Aragorn doesn't at all. Which would seem like he never was too deep in there, and not taken the whole journey even from East to West.
Whatever the reason for his entering to Moria was, it was surely not nice, and I'd consider it something like a "ranger issue", not concerning Gandalf or the Wise or the Dwarves. That's just my feeling, not based on any evidence. However, it certainly wasn't anything super-important, because it's not mentioned anywhere.
|
RE a - Aragorn describes his memory of the place as "very evil" which , given my impression of him as someone not easily cowed, suggests to me that he must have been in Moria for more than a few minutes, hours or days more likely, for the place to leave that impression on him.
RE c - When discussing possible pathways through Moria, Gandalf consults Gimli, not Aragorn. Aragorn seems content to make no input into their conversations on the matter. However, whatever the state of Aragorn's knowledge of Moria, he could not have lead the Fellowship through it. Gandalf after all was the one with the light.
Quote:
Boromir muttered under his breath, ... "Who will lead us in this deadly dark?"
"I will" said Gandalf .... "Follow my staff!" As the wizard passed on ahead up the great steps, he held his staff aloft, and from its tip there came a faint radiance"
A Journey in the Dark, FotR
|
Reason for entry into Moria
Legate, I wouldn't describe it as not "super important". If Moria is not the preferred pathway or destination for anyone, not even Gollum, then whatever prompted Aragorn to enter Moria was a matter of some importance. Also, if "Lord of the Rings" is taken as an account originally written by Frodo, then the fact that we are not told why Aragorn entered Moria may simply indicate that it was a matter outside Frodo's knowledge.