Ok, I'll toss in this document as it might bring some discussion:
Votes: Day 1
Xyzzy –> Lommy 1
Di -> Legate 1
Sleepy -> Rune 1
Menel -> Rikae 1
Celuien -> Kitanna 1
Sixth -> Gil 1
Rikae -> Menel 1
Rune -> Menel 2
Boro -> Legate 2
Lommy -> Celuien 1
Roa -> Celuien 2
Aganzir -> Celuien 3
Mac -> Celuien 4
Nogrod -> Rikae 2
SPM -> Kitanna 2
Brinniel -> Rikae 3
Lynched: Celuien
Night 2
Di -> Protect: The Saucepan Man
Nogrod -> Hunt: Boromir
Rikae -> Dream: Macalaure
Kitanna -> SDream: Eomer
Gil -> VHunt: Nogrod
Eomer -> VDream: Thinlomien
Legate -> VProtect: Legate
Vampires kill: Brinniel
Lynch Seer: Eomer of the Rohirrim
Votes: Day 2
Xyzzy -> Rune 1
Di -> Nogrod 1
Shasta -> Gil 1
Kitanna -> Rikae 1
Sixth -> Rikae 2
Rikae -> Legate 1
Rune -> Menel 1
Durelin -> Boro 1
Mac -> Rikae 3
Lommy -> Menel 2
Aganzir -> Menel 3
Nogrod -> Menel 4
SPM -> Menel 5
Roa -> Nogrod 2
Lynched: Menel
Night 3
Nogrod -> Hunt: Boro
Rikae -> Dream: Boro
Di -> Protect: Eomer
Kitanna -> SKill: Eomer (Protected)
Legate -> VProtect: None
Eomer -> VDream: Durelin
Gil -> VHunt: Roa
Vampires kill: Roa
Lynch Seer: Nogrod
Votes: Day 3
Di -> Glirdan 1
Xyzzy -> Nogrod 1
Sixth -> Durelin 1
Rikae -> SPM 1
SPM -> Legate 1
Shasta -> Legate 2
Lommy -> SPM 2
Boro -> SPM 3
Kitanna -> Eomer 1
Rune -> Legate 3
Aganzir -> SPM 4
Durelin -> Legate 4
Mac -> Legate 5
Nogrod -> SPM 5
Lynched: Legate
Night 4
Rikae -> Dream: Lommy
Di -> Protect: Rikae
Nogrod -> Hunt: Legate
Kitanna -> SProtect: Rikae
Gil-Galad -> VHunt: SPM (2. Rikae, 3. Boromir)
Legate -> VProtect: Eomer
Eomer -> VDream: Aganzir
Vampires kill: Rikea (Twice protected.)
Lynch Seer: Boro
Votes: Day 4
Di -> Eomer 1
Sixth -> Eomer 2
Rikae -> Eomer 3
Kitanna -> Eomer 4
Rune -> Eomer 5
Xyzzy -> Eomer 6
Shasta -> Eomer 7
Lommy -> Eomer 8
Nogrod -> Eomer 9
SPM -> Eomer 10
Boro -> Eomer 11
Lynched: Eomer
Night 5
Nogrod -> Hunt: Gil
Di -> Protect: Kitanna
Rikae -> Dream: Aganzir
Shade -> Kill: Aganzir
Gil-Galad -> VHunt: SPM (2. Rikae, 3. Boromir)
Vampires kill: 1. Kitanna (2. Rikae 3. Nogrod 4. Boromir88)
Lynch Seer: Mac
LKill: Nogrod
EDIT: This might be flawed and in that case the whole game was flawed, but
