Nice
Eomer!
Sad that you forgot to give us the third innocent though...
Okay I'll make this a go one more time.
Spm is quite right with his concern on Day1 votes. If
Eomer and
Aganzir were vampires two of the four
Rikae-voters should have forgotten / mismanaged sending their votes. That sounds a bit improbable and makes Aganzir look innocent.
That might point towards
Gil being the last vampire. If he has no vote then
Rikae would have had only three votes and gaining them later than
Celuien, Cel died with three votes as well. On Day2 and Day3
Gil has voted quite monomaniacilly for
Shasta which I think is a pretty safe bet for a vampire not to be counted in any further tallies.
But there's a further problem still with Day2. As
Menel got 7 declared votes but only 5 actual ones then even counting
Legate out of the equation there's still one vote discrepancy. Someone forgot to send the actual vote then? That would be the easiest solution. Otherwise there is a liar in the group
Rune, Aganzir, Spm.
On Day3 we miss a vote. Only four declared votes for
Legate and there's five of them. That would make
Spm, Shasta Rune, Durelin look innocent as their votes are needed to lynch
Legate as there most probably was at least five votes on
Spm - and there were six declared ones.... And if no-one has forgotten to vote then
Aganzir is the only one whom we don't know. But we just saw her looking innocentish on Day1.
Cross-examining Days 2 and 3 we might clear
Spm and
Rune (oh my!). That would leave
Aganzir again! Checking at Day1 tends to clear her but still she is the answer to both problems in Day2 and 3...
So anyone wishing to admit forgetting to make the actual vote? It would require the least problem-solving if there just is something very fishy in Day1 voting and
Aganzir is our vampire... But if these problems on Day2 and 3 can be explained away, then I might consider looking at
Gil really carefully toMorrow.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
Nogrod, if you hunt Aganzir tonight, it will only make you a marvellous aim for the vampire if Aganzir is innocent.
|
That's the reason why I ended my last post with these words:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by me
But as a hunter I will not say anything and reserve my right to hunt whoever I see fit for the next Night.
|