The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Macalaure · 05-01-2007, 10:47 AM

Day Two

Menel voters (7, really 5):
Rune
Lommy
Aganzir
Mac
Espiem
Legate
Nogrod

1 is guilty and dead
1 is a known innocent
1 is very probably an innocent
4 are question marks

So one of the following four is either a wolf or a lying innocent.

Rune (early vote, one could argue a throwaway)
Lommy (Celuien voter on Day One*, even though her vote started the waggon against Menel, it does also look a little like an attempt to spread the votes further. But why should Vamplómien spread the vote when Legate was in danger?)
Aganzir (Celuien voter on Day One*, she got the waggon against Menel going)
Saucepan Man (shameless bandwaggoner, but if he was evil, he could have also thrown his vote away and saved himself from the heat)

*Keeping Eomer's very probable (unless Kitanna lies) guilt in mind, being a Celuien voter is no longer a thing that one would like to be.

Day Three

Unless some innocent filthily lied about his vote, there is at least one wolf among the SPM-voters, maybe even both (we will know more once we know how many votes Legate really received)

SPM-voters: Rikae (seer), Boro (ordo), Lommy, Aganzir, me (ordo), Nogrod (hunter)

That's Lommy and Aganzir again!

05-01-2007, 10:47 AM	#501
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	Catching up Day Two Menel voters (7, really 5): Rune Lommy Aganzir Mac Espiem Legate Nogrod 1 is guilty and dead 1 is a known innocent 1 is very probably an innocent 4 are question marks So one of the following four is either a wolf or a lying innocent. Rune (early vote, one could argue a throwaway) Lommy (Celuien voter on Day One, even though her vote started the waggon against Menel, it does also look a little like an attempt to spread the votes further. But why should Vamplómien spread the vote when Legate was in danger?) Aganzir* (Celuien voter on Day One, she got the waggon against Menel going) Saucepan Man* (shameless bandwaggoner, but if he was evil, he could have also thrown his vote away and saved himself from the heat) Keeping Eomer's very probable (unless Kitanna* lies) guilt in mind, being a Celuien voter is no longer a thing that one would like to be. Day Three Unless some innocent filthily lied about his vote, there is at least one wolf among the SPM-voters, maybe even both (we will know more once we know how many votes Legate really received) SPM-voters: Rikae (seer), Boro (ordo), Lommy, Aganzir, me (ordo), Nogrod (hunter) That's Lommy and Aganzir again!