[Thinlómien]

Happy birthday, Sixth!

I'm growing slightly worried about Mac. He seems to be slipping under everybody's radar. Nobody's suspecting him, nobody's almost even talking about him. How is this possible? I understand people let Celuien-voters slip under their radar at this phase, but Mac is a Legate-voter - a group I'm fairly sure at least one vampire is hiding in. I don't think Mac is very suspicious, but I'm worried of him slipping under the radar, especially as he's been more silent than usually - is he trying to contribute to his slipping under the radar by this?

Originally Posted by Sauce

It is possible, if the lynchee is innocent, that a Vampiric Lynch Seer might post a riddle if he or she is sufficiently certain that the lynchee will name an innocent.

I agree here. And I think a vampire lynch seer might post the riddle even if s/he wasn't even sure who the lynchee was to take with her/him - we've seen backstabbing and double-bluffing wolves before, haven't we? So I don't think it's very wise to draw conclusions from the lynch seers' actions, or at least one must be careful when doing it.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

So you kind of wish to say that I'm suspicious because I make a suggestion of looking at another direction for a while but you still manage to pick a few from my list to look after as well...

No, I don't. I think it's a good thing to take into account and (to some level) suspect everyone. It just seems to me that you're quite forcefully attacking at all directions yet not concentrating on making a solid case against anyone. Doesn't look very innocent to me.

(And by the way, Nogrod, I've not said let's not lynch the silent people. In fact, if I don't have any serious-ish suspects and there's no rule about modfire, I will most probably vote some inactive player - Sleepy, Glirdy or Xyzzy..)

Nogrod and Roa both worry me. I mean, they're both smart, reasonable players. However, in this game they've both been making more or less weak cases and then accused each other of making weak cases. I don't think this is very normal of them. And I can't help thinking that a vampire-Noggie and a vampire-Roa might co-operate in this way...

Originally Posted by Sauce

Apart from her blind spot on Rikae, I see nothing to concern me about her.

Well, to state it, I don't find Rikae particularly innocent. Her weird responses to your questions toDay do make me wary of her. Yet I don't see why are you and some other people so very suspicious of her. I think she's worth watching, but I don't think she screams a vampire.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

And as you're not to believe my word on it (now why would you?) just ask yourself the question would anyone sane enough speak and act (=vote) like I have done if I were a Vampire? There are so many easier ways to accomplish the thing...

Yes. Anyone who's been a baddie at once knows that it's not a simple thing and anyone who's played werewolf a lot *coughyoucough* should know that baddies do the most astonishing and unreasonable- and unsafe-seeming things.

Menel, in your post #233 you seem to think that Eomer said that he had not case against Kit means that he did not suspect her. I think that's not a very good conclusion. One can be suspicious of someone without making a case against him/her. This was only to point a fault in Menel's logic - personally I interpret Eomer's posts the way he wasn't (at leats a lot) suspicious of Kitanna himself.

edit: xed with Mac - glad to see him around