The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Macalaure · 04-10-2007, 06:02 AM

I tried to come up with something interesting, but failed. So here's an overview of my suspicions right now, just to appear helpful.

Gil-Galad ~ *shrug*

Legate of Amon Lanc ~ fairly unsuspicious. He defends tgwbs even as he was already clearly going down. A wolf might do that, to say "I told you he was innocent" afterwards, but a wolf would have done that differently in some way, I think.

Mithalwen ~ she is somewhat strange, but I get an innocent feel from her

Nogrod ~ even though I still could imagine him being evil, I doubt it. Nogrod is a Sportswolf, and he wouldn't have gone the way to pursue a lynching of xyzzy. I rather guess an innocent Nogrod who doesn't know what else to do would have.

Rikae ~ I looked over her posts again and found nothing suspicious. I'm unfamiliar with a totally unsuspicious Rikae, and therefore wary.

Roa_Aoife ~ I more and more find myself thinking: If Roa is evil, she deserves to win. I really find nothing suspicious about her.

The Sixth Wizard ~ unsuspicious

Thinlómien ~ The cobbler tries to lynch her and innocent Brinn thought her "more innocent than anything". I'm sorry, but I still suspect her like I did yesterDay.

xyzzy ~ ?

Two wolves are probably left and I find everybody but Lommy innocent. Gil? Are Legate or Rikae fooling me marvelously? Or is it really Nogrod in the end? This is frustrating.

04-10-2007, 06:02 AM	#4
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	I tried to come up with something interesting, but failed. So here's an overview of my suspicions right now, just to appear helpful. Gil-Galad ~ shrug Legate of Amon Lanc ~ fairly unsuspicious. He defends tgwbs even as he was already clearly going down. A wolf might do that, to say "I told you he was innocent" afterwards, but a wolf would have done that differently in some way, I think. Mithalwen ~ she is somewhat strange, but I get an innocent feel from her Nogrod ~ even though I still could imagine him being evil, I doubt it. Nogrod is a Sportswolf, and he wouldn't have gone the way to pursue a lynching of xyzzy. I rather guess an innocent Nogrod who doesn't know what else to do would have. Rikae ~ I looked over her posts again and found nothing suspicious. I'm unfamiliar with a totally unsuspicious Rikae, and therefore wary. Roa_Aoife ~ I more and more find myself thinking: If Roa is evil, she deserves to win. I really find nothing suspicious about her. The Sixth Wizard ~ unsuspicious Thinlómien ~ The cobbler tries to lynch her and innocent Brinn thought her "more innocent than anything". I'm sorry, but I still suspect her like I did yesterDay. xyzzy ~ ? Two wolves are probably left and I find everybody but Lommy innocent. Gil? Are Legate or Rikae fooling me marvelously? Or is it really Nogrod in the end? This is frustrating.