Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Roa
I wasn't acting surprised; I was surprised. To be perfectly honest, I had given virtually no thought to Brin whatsoever. Seeing as Sixth's voting record had/ has almost the entire village convinced he's innocent, I was fully expecting the wolves to take him out.
|
Seconded. Even if Roa is lying at that moment to save her neck, this makes perfect sense.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Roa
Something interesting- Day 1, Glirdan and TGWBS both had the same three suspects. [Roa, Six, Lommy]
|
Interesting. If I now based my accusations mainly on what Glirdy and TGWBS did, it would cast rather positive light on Lommy - or if Lommy was a wolf, this would be the meanest trick I've ever seen from both the Cobbler and Glirdan.
But what Roa said about the same suspect does not necessarily prove anything - the common suspects were the three persons who were the most in the spotlight at that time, and it's only logical for the wolves (and their allies) to join accusing bandwaggons, at least a little bit.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Roa
As for Brin, she was highly suspected Day 1, and had enough suspicion on Day 2 that she doesn't seem that obvious of a wolf kill. It leads me to wonder why her and not Sixth, who was trusted by almost everyone?
|
Well, sorry, but this is extremely wolvish. "Hello folks. This and this happened. But wait - this looks strange. WHAT DO YOU THINK...?" Provoking a nowhere leading discussion, which could be as well the reason to kill Brinniel. (One wolf to another: Heya, let's kill Brinn, they'll spend half time debating about why the heck we killed her and not Sixth! - Yeah, yeah, pal, that's a good idea!) So unless anyone has any positive conclusion from why Brinn was killed, I suggest leave it and not post questions which raise debate. The only logical conclusion from someone posting a question to which he himself does not have an answer is that he is hoping someone else to look at it - and post an answer. But why not look at it myself´? You cannot trust the others' answers on that, unless you know they are innocent. So why even bring it up, unless it is a vital question, worthy very much to the village? I don't think this is the case - there are no direct evidencies like Brinniel being a powerful person capable of starting a bandwaggon against one of the wolves, so that the wolves had to kill her. Unless someone has any real evidence, I'd leave this matter.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Macalaure
I'm not really surprised they went for Brinniel. Because of these stupid meta-reasons she and Six look(ed) very innocent. Probably the wolves thought Brinn more of a threat than Six. Her opinions are worthy of a second look. Hopefully she was more than just the greater potential threat.
|
Yes, or this is another possibility of what the wolves might have thought. I doubt we can read something significant from this one. After all, wolves are wolves and do NOT want to be found.
To the whole TGWBS-Roa-whoeverelsewasthereatthestart issue, we should bear in mind that it was logical for TGWBS to "test water" for who the wolves might be (e.g. as I said earlier, "There is probably at least one wolf in the Roa-Glirdan-Rikae triangle" - TGWBS might have thought similar way). Just to bear this one in mind.
I'll be back! Said Arnie the Senator.