Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
tgwbs for Lommy ~ If he's evil, then this vote would have been good move to save Glirdan. His reasoning isn't the best.
|
This is a point with which I don't disagree at all!  I must say I will be looking tgwbs much more closely toDay. He raised my suspicions yesterDay and this kind of stuff brings me back to suspect him even more. Good point. |
Um, I only said it would've been a good move to save
Glirdan, which is actually quite obvious, and not a very good point. And "His reasoning isn't the best" surely isn't.
It's weird you point this one out like that.
Concerning
Brinniel, I think I'll buy her explanations for yesterday. I'll put her back to 'averagely suspicious'.
Roa's analysis, wow... truly excellent. *bows*
... and appetizing as well. Is anybody else fancying a waffle right now?
Let's have a look at
Nog's voting situation:
If
Nogrod is evil, then in all probability either
tgwbs or
Lommy aren't (4 wolves in a village of 13? No way.)
Case 1:
Lommy is evil.
Wouldn't he have secretly welcomed my vote for
tgwbs then? Sure he wouldn't be open about it, but why'd he be so adverse to it? I think an evil
Nogrod would've reacted along the lines of "tgwbs? Hmm, yeah, well, maybe, what do the others think?" Unless.. he was already sure he wanted to do some backstabbing at this point, and my vote gave an alternative he didn't, in fact, welcome anymore.
Case 2:
tgwbs is evil.
Nogrod's "tgwbs is suspicious but I will rather shoot into the dark than vote for him" looks horrible in this light. Actually, it looks almost too horrible and obvious.
Case 3: they're both innocent.
In that case,
Nogrod had
all the options he wanted to save
Glirdan without drawing attention to himself. If we were talking about anybody else but
Nogrod, I would probably dismiss this possibility, but Glirdan's game, where Wolfgrod lynched more wolves than the innocents did, still gives me shudders.
I'm really puzzled about
Nogrod and looking forward to his reaction to
Roa.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
People seem rather edgy and snappy considering that we're doing really well, one wolf dead and no dead innocents this far...  |
You know,
these are the tiny things that really make my alarms ring. Why,
why, would an innocent say things along the lines of: "Oh, come on, we're doing well, let's just play it the easy way now"?
edit: crossed with Lommy's last two