I just have a moment to check the posts now, but I'll be around before the deadline.
Right now the whole
Glirdan issue is most attention grabbing. While I raised an eyebrow at the way
Glirdan's second post seems to misrepresent the issues, I can't decide whether to believe it's willful misrepresentation or innocent misunderstanding. The blending of "oh, pretty butterfly..." in character comments with suspicion feels off to me too, but I'll reserve judgement for the time being.
Something about
TGWBS bugs me. He says that
Roa's first post is "trying to sound helpful without being helpful", and that phrase immediately jumped out at me. It's become sort of a stock-accusation that's easy to fling around, and doesn't really make sense so early in the game. It seems a little too generalized, and especially bothers me coupled with the suspicion toward
Thinlomien for voting early (in my experience, she almost always does, and I think
TGWBS knows that).
I also wonder why he wouldn't want a hunter to reveal:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by The Guy Who Be Short
I'd rather a more important gifted (the Hunter isn't that important) declared themselves rather than letting themselves be killed. .
|
If I'm not mistaken, an ordinary hunter only kills if he/she is killed by wolves. It seems to me the wolves would like very much to have a hunter safely lynched, rather than revealed.
I don't care for
Legate's defeatist attitude; we may have slim chances of catching a wolf on day one, but they are certainly better if we actually make an effort!
EDIT: x'd with Gil and Mac
EDIT2: Oh yeah, just Mac. I forgot seeing Gil's post.