[Gothbogg the Ripper]

For battles: The Two Towers
For story: The Return of The King
For characters: The Return of The King
For music: The Return of The King
For effects: The Two Towers

So for me The Return of The King is the best. There was simply nothing like it. The end credits, the introduction of the Witch-King, Aragon's speech. Everything was perfect. Those 11 Oscar's were utterly earned no matter what some pompous, irrational, fat, stinky, smelly, gross, loser, boozer, no hope Trotskyite tells you.