I have been reviewing the thread to see what people’s attitudes were to TGWBS and what his attitude was to everyone still here. Here’s a “rough and ready” list:
Durelin: TGWBS claimed throughout to find find her neutral. She has never expressed more than mild suspicion of him.
Gil-Galad: TGWBS suspected him yesterDay. TGWBS was on Gil’s list of suspects from the start. They voted for each other yesterDay.
Hookbill the Goomba: TGWBS expressed mild suspicion of him fairly late on. I don’t think that Hookbill has mentioned him once.
Kath: TGWBS said that he was slightly troubled by her. On Day 3, she found him “unbelievably suspicious” but thought this might be down to different playing style and history, from which she concluded that she had no idea about him.
Kitanna: TGWBS said that he was leaning to her innocence. I‘m not sure that she has mentioned him.
Lalaith: TGWBS claimed to suspect her early on, analysed her on Day 2, and then said that she did not look suspicious to him. He did, however, express suspicion of her yesterDay. She has been moderately suspicious of him for a while, and voted for him yesterDay, before switching to me.
Legate of Amon Lanc: TGWBS claimed to be uneasy about him. Legate seems to have been neutral about him.
Mithalwen: TGWBS expressed strong suspicion of her early on, but then eased off from about Day 2, saying that he thought her more likely innocent. She has remained neutral about him, saying little one way or the other.
The Saucepan Man: I was suspicious of TGWBS from Day 2. TGWBS said that he thought me probably innocent.
Thinlómien: TGWBS claimed to suspect her on Day 2, seemingly in response to her case against him, but then seems to have eased off. She strongly suspected TGWBS from Day 2, and voted for him on Day 2.
It is difficult to know exactly how TGWBS would have chosen to react to his fellow Faithfuls, or they to him. I am, however, interested in those about whom he said very little, and vice versa, namely:
Durelin
Hookbill
Kitanna
Legate
However, I strongly doubt that he would have affected the same attitude to all of his comrades. Which leads me to believe that there is probably only one Faithful on that list. There might be two, but I think that he would have been more careful than that.
I am curious about Kath’s view on him. I think it was Lalaith who picked her up yesterDay on it, and she did explain it. But I don’t like the way she seems to have found him very suspicious, yet gave herself an excuse not to vote for him.
TGWBS appears to have expressed no strong suspicions of anyone, of those still living, save for Gil-Galad. But I find their approach to each other yesterDay most unlikely to have been the behaviour of two Faithfuls.
His expressed opinons changed most with regard to Lalaith and Lommy and, to a lesser extent, Mithalwen. It is quite possible that he would have adapted his approach to his fellow Faithfuls as game progressed and, of these I find Lalaith the most suspicious. Lommy’s consistent suspicion of him, and her Day 2 vote for him, makes me think it unlikely that she is a Faithful. I am somewhat wary of the fact that Mithalwen never really expressed much of an opinion about him but I somehow doubt that he would so firmly have adopted a belief in the innocence of a fellow Faithful so early on. From my perspective, his stated belief in my own innocence also leads me to think that.
So, based on my analyses so far, here are my current thoughts:
Suspicious
Durelin
Lalaith
Hookbill
Somewhat suspicious
Kath
Kitanna
Legate
Inclined to think innocent
Mithalwen
Lommy
Gil-Galad
And now I must sleep …
|