Brinniel - She's way too silent to my taste. I understand she wants to do some research because she does not know our wwing styles, but still... She's very careful, she manages a consistency suspecting Hookbill and her votes are bandwagoning or safe. I can very easily see a newcomer wolf doing this.... (but on the other hand, I can see an innocent newcomer doing it too). I'll be watching her.
Durelin - see my last post.
Gil-Galad - I'm slightly annoyed by his playing style, but that's what happens always...
I think he's pretty genuine, though it's very difficult to say since there's so little to go on. If he's a wolf he'll be really dangerous, I'm afarid, since he manages to slip under the radar...
the guy who be short - I think I've pretty much said what I think about him. His suggestions are wolvish and so is his carefulness.
Hookbill the Goomba - It's difficult to read him. I don't like the fact that he hides behind his claimed bad reading of people and his (relative) newbieshness and that he spends most of the time either emphasising these or defending himself. This behaviour doesn't make him suspicious per se, since I don't know if he's always like that; that might be his playing style. And he doesn't give very faithfulish feel or anything. I just have the feeling that though his name is continuously brought up, he still manages to slip under the radar.
Kath - She's as she's always. Relatively silent, but helpful and contributing. Innocent or guilty. You can never decipher. She feels innocent, but one should not trust gut-feeling too much. If she's a wolf, she can be nailed after we've lynched some/one of her companions. According to my experiences, that is almost the only way to catch a kathwolf. I will take a closer look at her after we've got a wolf, but for now I'm ready to consider her innocent-ish.
Kitanna - I'm not sure if I trust her. She seems reasonable, yes. On the first Day she was mainly only agreeing and parroting. That made me wary. YesterDay and toDay she's been a bit different. But there's still something about her that does not sit right with me. I guess it might have something to do with her calm, sly manner, and I always tend to suspect her, at least a bit. If I have time toDay, I will take a closer look at her.
Lalaith - Hmmm... I dislike her NogGod-suggestions (and think them suspicious) and there's something weird about her (like the Day1 retraction which Nogrod pointed out)... But somehow the feel of her doesn't strike me as particularly suspicious. I don't know.
Legate of Amon Lanc - First Day, I thought he was very reasonable, calm and innocent-looking. Now I'm not too sure. Like someone said, he's a bit too quick to agree. What's funny is that while Rune became less suspicious about him after the long post yesterDay, I became more so. Somehow, it just didn't sit right with me. Yet there is some innocentishness in him too... A tough one.
Mänwe - I'm inclined to think he's innocent. Like Rune said, he's being too weird and making far too much mess to be a wolf.
Mithalwen - Another tough one. She feels innocent, but less than the last time I played with her. She's concentarting on things an innocent wouldn't maybe concentrate on (like the Roa-SPM-Nogrod triangle on Day1), but her consistence in demanding to lynch someone else than Roa (which I could very well understand) speaks for her innocence.
Nogrod - Known innocent.
Rune Son of Bjarne - I always tend to sympathise with him, and I don't know why. But in this game my initial feeling towards him has been less sympathic. Is my subconscious right? Is there something wrong with Rune? Might be. His Legate-case and his votes have been quite worriesome... But on the other hand, he has been very reasonable at times, and innocently reasonable, if you ask me.
The Saucepan Man - How much ever you others have debated about him, he has managed to slip under my radar. I have not formed a proper picture of him yet. I can't see anything that especially speaks for his innocence, nor anything that speaks for his guilt. He's reasonable and has good points, but that's what he does as a wolf as well.
Thinlómien - Obviously innocent.
~*~
While writing this, I realised my opinions about most people were "I don't know" or "a tough one" or "could be evil or good"...
Well, at least I learned I need more reread and more thinking. But it troubles me that I can't get a proper grasp on people.
EDIT: xed with Hookbill and TGWBS... avoided triple posting