|
A meta-analysis.
We have two known innocents. In addition, we have one known Tar-Miriel (surely you people are not serious about having doubts? A fake-seer lying about having seen Tar-Miriel is illogical).
I have put together their views concerning every villager, except for themselves, of course. (In the case of Roa, as she is working to undermine the village, remember to invert everything she says). I will then compare what these three people think about each villager. Let's see what happens:
Brinniel
Roa thinks Brinniel is "odd." I think she's largely undecided here.
Durelin
Roa seems to find her slightly suspicious, which means she probably thinks durelin is innocent.
Gil-Galad
Roa has no strong feelings, is slightly suspicious.
Glirdan
Nogrod is ever so slightly suspicious, but his feelings aren't strong.
the guy who be short
Roa seems to find me suspicious, though does not go as far as thinking I'm a Faithful. She probably thinks I'm innocent.
Nogrod worries that he agrees with everything I say. I think this means he's largely undecided on me.
Hookbill the Goomba
Roa seems to find him suspicious, but not so much as to call him a wolf. She probably think's he's an innocent.
Kath
Roa has no strong feelings, slightly suspicious.
Nogrod doesn't seem to have any strong feelings.
Kitanna
Roa suspects her to be Faithful, which probably means she think's Kitanna is innocent.
Lalaith
Roa suspects her, though not so far as to call her a wolf. She therefore probably finds Lalaith innocent.
Legate of Amon Lanc
Roa "likes" and "agrees" with everything he says. She says somebody else should analyze him because she feels too partial. This points to her thinking he is a Faithful.
Mänwe
Roa calls him suspicious, meaning she probably thinks he's innocent.
Nogrod thinks he is not a Faithful.
Rikae thinks he is suspicious.
Mithalwen
Roa has no strong feelings, she's slightly suspicious.
Rune Son of Bjarne
Roa seems to find him suspicious, which probably means she thinks he's innocent.
The Saucepan Man
Roa attacks him fiercely, meaning she thinks he's innocent.
Nogrod attacks him fiercely, he thinks SpM is a faithful.
Thinlómien
Rikae thinks she has a "faithful-ish vibe."
Roa thinks she seems quite innocent, meaning she probably thinks Thinlomien is Faithful.
Well. Some more views from Nogrod and Rikae would certainly help matters. The following names are only from people whom at least 2 of our known 3 characters have commented on. As it stands, these people look worst:
Lommy
These people look neutral:
TGWBS
Kath
Manwe
SpM
Dear Annatar! Everybody else comes under "not enough data." Nogrod and Rikae, please share your opinions on people. This type of meta-analysis can be very helpful, I feel.
|