[Kath]

OOC: Ok. Essay is done, internet is working, let's get down to some serious game playing!

Well, I was about to ask whether anyone else thought Roa was posting like a mad woman in order to put people off analysing her for some dastardly reason, and thanks to Rikae I have an answer! For all that some people have said we might as well leave her alive since she's not a Faithful I think it would be worth killing her. Firstly we're rid of a most confusing influence, and second the thread will get a good bit shorter!

Roa reviewed almost everyone before Rikae came out with her dream, but of course she has no more idea on who the wolves are than we do so I'm not sure how much help those will be. It is possible that those she thinks look more innocent may actually be Faithfuls thanks to Cobbler logic, but since she doesn't know for sure nor do we.

However, on Day 1 she did specifically say she thought Manwe was either Cobbler or Faithful, which I think clears him slightly. Roa's bold, but I'm not sure she'd be so bold as to add support to an already forming bandwagon if she thought he really might be a wolf. Not that early on in the game.

I have to admit that I skim read all of those long analyses today and so can't say anything about them yet. I'll go back and read them, see if they give me any ideas.

EDIT: Cross-posted with at least 3/4 people.