[Roa_Aoife]

Nogrod (Because I have to)

1st post – Thinks we have a good chance of winning, agrees with Mith about
the dangers of lynching a gifted, finds Lalaith’s posts odd, thinks we
should lynch the nice ones, doesn’t want to lynch Thin, Holby and Mith, says
it’s hard to jump on anyone just now.

2nd post – First impression: Mith- innocent, Lalaith- hasty but innocent,
Manwe- unknown, Kath- unkown, Glirdan- suspicious

(Why do people do this? I never understood.)

3rd post - Says he's not trusting anyone, banter with Roa

4th post - Worried that he's agreeing with Roa, thinks Glirdan is too detached, suggests looking at attitude, agrees with SPM about talking

(That would worry me, too, if it wasn't what we always agree on)

5th post - Says SPM is being hypocritical, and blowing things out of proportion, thus making SPM suspicious

(I can see his point about SPM. Infact some other things bothered me about him.)

I actually don't see anything here other than typical Nogrod. I don't believe he "jumped on" Glirdan at all, and at one point he even agreed with Kitanna that it would be beneficial to wait and see what Glirdan had to say. All the cases against him don't seem to hold much merit with that in mind.

So, his great accuser, Manwe:

1st post – immediately points to newbiness, and typical quietness, suspects
that everyone will feel odd, brings up double bluffing, throws vague
suspicion on Hookbill

(Ah, the good old "Newbie" defense.)

2nd post - thinks Nogrod and Roa are suspicious for being too harsh on the quiet, response to SPM's suspicions?, jumps on hookbill line from SPM

(For someone who accuses other of jumping onto easy targets, he seems mighty jumpy himself.)

3rd post - says the four faithfuls are Nogrod, Roa, Saucepan Man, and Kitanna, says Nogrod hasn't answered his questions yet, thinks this makes him guilty, says Roa and Nogrod are picking on Glirdan to draw suspicion from themselves

(A bold statement, but nothing to back it)

4th post - again, grabs onto Hookbill line from SPM

(SPM's clearly joking, but Manwe seems almost serious about this.)

5th post - says since there are four faithful, he names four suspects, doesn't think it's odd, calls back to remember other innocent who were lynched, asks Durelin to reconsider, says he would only vehemently deny being a faithful if he was one, says he may be wrong, but would wait until Nogrod answered his questions, cross posted, said Kitanna's suspicion of Glirdan makes her suspicious

(His defense here is full of holes and shady aspects. Firstly, spotting all four wolves on Day 1 is impossible, secondly, a good portion of the village wasn't even present at this point. It just screams of recklessness. Also, pointing to all the innocents who were lynched for being too suspicious looks designed to cause hesitation in everyone. Also, what question did he ask Nogrod that was vital? I've been keeping a running summary of everything written, and even I missed it.)

6th post - suggest that everything is baseless right now

(If everything is baseless, what are you blathering on about?)

7th post - Understands Kitanna now, says flying accusations are only natural, explains his suspcion as people who pounced apon Glirdan, except for SPM, who was just a baseless accusation to stir things up, but does suspect him on grasping onto his Hookbill idea

(Flying accusations never helped the village. At best, they confuse and focus our attention on a select few, blinding us to whatever else lays out there.)

8th post - Says throwing accusations about is nothing new, says he's just trying to get other's ideas flowing, Votes Nogrod

(How can it not be new for you if this is your first time playing? This screams cop-out to me.)

Conclusion: If he's not a Faithful, he's the Cobbler.

SPM next.