Eh just I thought... but I think pethaps that even though this isn't a "real" legend is in something passed down for hundreds and hundreds of generations and reallt created by one man maybe Tolkien never really wanted us to have just one version of the story... (The Silm making him seem less insane and the other not so or who is suppose kill, Morgoth or whatever) because when we have lots of different version it makes it seem more real... because real myths always have different versions from different people. I like it this way it makes it all seem more real... don't know if any of you agree but by all means keep discussing. I find it all facinating!
__________________
Member of:
The Bodyparts of Sauron
Russ 2006
|