[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Ang

++FEANOR OF THE PEREDHIL

Heh heh heh... Fea is thrilled, I'm sure.

Originally Posted by Kath

Those who are dying at Night ... morm, lmp and Roa. Is there anything that links them?

The only thing that I can think of is what I said earlier- they're all from my side of the Atlantic. I don't think anyone else commented on that strategy though, so I guess that means it's off the wall.

The only other common thing that I see is that the choices from the last two nights (lmp and Roa) were unusual choices. Both were in line to be lynched, it seems to me. Personally, I would've killed Nogrod last night.

Originally Posted by SPM

The two most recent kill choices were strange ones. Perhaps this Wolf is one who is trying to give himself more of a challenge by killing off the more suspected villagers and leaving the less suspected ones. The phantom himself stated early on that, given the random nature of this game, he would feel little pride in winning it as a Wolf. Perhaps, therefore, having been selected as a Wolf, he is trying to make it more of a challenge for himself.

Ha ha! I love your line of thought.

You're wrong, but it's amusing.

Honestly, do you think I'd kill lmp and Roa?

You've seen me as a WW in two villages, SPM. When have I ever killed a juicy lynch target? No, no, no... I kill the Seer, and then I kill more peripheral villagers- ones who are a bit quieter, ones who aren't associated with me, and most importantly ones who aren't in line to be lynched.

I always make a logical kill. If everyone shows up in the morning asking "Why them?" then you can bet I didn't do it. It's a fact.

You will notice that in the villages where I was a WW I never once questioned the kills or insisted that I would've done something different.

Originally Posted by SPM

That and my paranoia finally won out ...

++ the phantom

Paranoia indeed.

So, I guess this vote for me means that you never understood what I was talking about on day one- about why you should trust me?

Oh well. I'll let it go for now. But if I continue to attract votes I suppose I will then feel obligated to explain what I was driving at on Day 1.

Originally Posted by Mith

There is that other outside possibility that Morm was a wolf and Fea is messing with our heads by picking off unlikely folk at night.

That thought has occured to me several times, but seeing as we have not been dismissed by our master I don't think there's anything to do besides continue lynching.

Originally Posted by Mith

TP' knowingness (is that even a word) still bothers me ...

What "knowingness"? I don't know much at all. If I did then the other WW would be dead by now.

About Nogrod's suspicions of Ang- he speaks truth, in the sense that his points are very valid and his theory is believable. Nogrod also was not surprised by the choice of Roa. He said there were a "bunch of reasons" to kill her. So not only was Nogrod not thrown off by Roa's death, but he seems to have easily formulated believable and logical suspicions to go along with it.

Is it just me, or does this remind anyone of when they were a WW? When I was a WW I always had theories that were pretty darn sound in their logic, for I didn't want to call attention to myself by putting forth bad theories. I crafted them carefully, either for myself or for one of my brother/sister WWs to present the following day. Also, when I was a WW, the kills never surprised me (duh), and I was always able to easily give "bunches of reasons" as to why the person was killed.

I'm completely aware that this is probably just a false alarm and that poor Nog hasn't done anything wrong, but I just have to speak my mind. Nog is making me nervous.

Oh, and nice list, Mith. I think I now know why SPM wants to kill me. He wants to take the lead in posting count.

I won't let it happen Sauce!!