Okay. I'm only an innocent, not one who knows things... as you know. So if there is to be a toMorrow (hopefully not!), remember I may be wrong here. I have been very wrong many times in this game.
But as it looks to me now.
Farael is probably innocent. His rant with
Boro is very hard to interpret as a wolf-on-wolf one. Too dangerous, too noisy. I mean, someone could have taken a point or two from their arguments and start a wagon to lynch him.
-----
CoD has also an unwolvish air about him just because he plays in the style he plays and gets almost everyone annoyed by it. A wolf would have to be really a daring one to risk that kind of play, standing up over all the village. Jsut look at the amount of suspicion he has gathered around him.
-----
Valier does pose a problem to me.
First of all I must agree with
Durelin here. When
Valier refused to break the tie between
CoD and
Ang (effectually on that point letting
CoD die) I thought it very suspicious washing-hands, but with reread she seems innocent enough.
In #96 she suspects most of us with points (and softenings with many) but not
Boro. Then she says there is a no clue -group consisting of
Farael,
Rune and
Naria... I don't know what to make of it.
After
Naria informed us that she was sick she came to talk on her behalf in #112.
Quote:
|
(OOC I know Naria in RL and she is really truly vomity flu sick, so please donot hold that against her or vote for her just for this reason.)
|
and later in #177
Quote:
|
I don't want to just Naria slide, but I hate to vote for someone who hasn't been around to defend themselves. That's not saying that she isn't a wolf, just that I think the possibility of CoD being a wolf is higher at the moment.
|
A good friend might stand up like this but a sneaky wolf might go this way too (there could be defences if she was later accused of this).
Unlike
Durelin, I find
Valier's speculation about
Rune's death quite reasonable. Just lately she has also sounded good. But surely the last remaining wolf would like to do that?
I'm somewhat unsure about her. I feel her innocent but am afraid she's the last one.
-----
Lommy I think to be most probably innocent, but then again, there is a fantastic plot that could be under everything here.
After
Naria informed us that she was sick there came the Night. Now if she told the other wolves that she can't participate, so why not to use that to their advantage? So
Boro and
Lommy came up with this idea:
Lommy makes a theory pointing at
Naria and
Boro is against it. That way they could distance themselves from each other nicely, adding some mild suspicion over each other to spice it a bit. Remember, they were sitting steady in the lead here and
Boro was in the
Fea-game too and was thence ready to take a risk of being the one of them who might be spotted. And with that trust our
Lommywolf will sail through to win the game...
Nice conspiration-theory, but as
Di said earlier, we tend to come up with more complex theories about wolves schemings as they actually go with. I'm not sure whether I (or anyone else) should give a second thought to that but I felt I had to say it.
Otherwise I see
Lommy to have been both reasonable and helpful villager and I tend to believe her innocent. Were she the last wolf I must say it would almost be an honour to lose to her.
-----
Volo I just can't read even now... I think I never had the skills to it. My lorebooks just tell me that last time he was a wolf and in a tight spot he tended to avoid playing but was available immediately when suspicions started to form. I can see some similarities with the pattern here.
I'll be here before the end but have to take a break for a while (and check also what's going oin in
Fea's game).