Lommy's dead, dead and innocent. An innocent Lommy is usually an asset to every village. Really, really bad. And I was even the first one to vote her...
*Note to self: don't go by your hunches, stupid*
And then Folwren was a Thing?? Now that's something I didn't expect. And she even defended me yesterday! Shame on you, Foley, shame on you!
I have some comments about what happened yesterday after I left.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rikae
Why does Mac say he agrees with Nogrod, when Nogrod has said that Mac looked suspicious?
|
I don't think in terms of "he thinks I'm suspicious, so I think he's suspicious". Some things I said yesterday can be interpreted suspiciously, so he had every right to. What he said made sense.
...until then. Just after I voted and left,
Nogrod started saying things that make me raise both my eyebrows today. Chance? Never!
I already thought it weird yesterday that he went after
Eonwe so early. So
Eo was a wolf the in the last village. So what??
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
A bit suspicious of:
Macalaure
Glirdan
Gil-Galad
Actually suspicious of:
Volo
Eonwe
Jenny
|
There's the short-spoken
Gil-Galad, the often silent
Eonwe (who hadn't even posted then), the relatively new
Volo, and
Glirdan who is known to have hunches that, well, don't really work out all the time (no offense intended, Glirdy, really) and often gets lynched for them.
We already said that the things will want to change stronger players at night. This leaves them with the less strong players as favourite day lynchs.
Nogrod here puts suspicion on 6 villagers, at least 4 of which one could regard as not-so-strong (
again: really, really, no offense to anybody, I mean that).
Jenny can be considered an easy target as well. Her foremothers always tended to get a little bit nervous when under suspicion.
He puts
Folwren as a sure innocent and I don't know what to make out of that.
Then there's
Nogrod's infamous vote-reasons post.
First off: why?
Why talk about everyone's reasons for voting at that time? He already voted
Jenny, so usually I'd expect him, or anybody, to a) try to get others into voting
Jenny too, b) try to get others into not voting for him (he was very concerned about that later), or c) bring up points that are new.
This post does neither.
And the way he does is - my goodness. He's not giving the reasons for most at all! He often just quotes something out of the vote-posts, and it's rarely flattering.
Menel's right in his criticism. I've seen somebody post like that before (Roa, Hithlum, wolf).
I also found his fear to be lynched a little over the top.
I don't think
Nogrod was the ranger yesterday. No way in Arda would he have asked questions about his role in public when he just could have pmed Valier for it. What is possible, I think, is that he laid out a lure for the real ranger, and that probably s/he accepted it in a way.
Jenny? Maybe. I have to think about this more.
I actually feel bad about suspecting
Nogrod so much, as he's not here today to defend himself. Normally I would say: forget about him, look for somebody else today, we can lynch him tomorrow in honour. But if he's a thing, he might not be here tomorrow, so I can't afford this opinion.
