|
Well said on oaths, Boromir.
Raynor, I think you are correct that Men could not generate magic but could manipulate items that bore or contained magic.
One such item would be a Man himself. This, I think, is what is going on with Beorn: he has by some unnamed means gotten Bear-soul in his being.
The Woses manipulate things that are fraught (or tainted depending on your pov) with magic.
Kingship is from way back in our own history an office loaded with magical roots. The gods would 'luck' a king, and as long as the king did what the gods wanted and not what they didn't want, their luck would stay with him, and thus he had healing from the gods. When he started losing battles, the folk he ruled would understand that the gods' luck had fallen from him and another must be found who was 'lucked' by the gods. This would relate to Aragorn as the king with healing hands in that authority is probably understood in Gondorian (descended from Numenorean) cirlces to derive from Eru. Thus Aragorn is "lucked" by Eru, in a manner of speaking.
My sense is that Bombadil is a creature of a different nature than the Elves. Whereas they held fëar of fire, Bombadil is an entity of Earth. All his magic is derived from the Earth. Whence from there? According to the cosmology, I would have to assume that it derived from Valinor and ultimately Eru, but that is drawing conclusions rather than based on anything Tolkien ever wrote.
|