Just a few comments on the game...
On wolves:
Volo cursed himself in the "What do you assign to Mordor"-thread. It was a bit sad he died so soon, but really, getting to a 2½ hours jog with a dog at the last hours of a game did sound a bit suspicious, avoiding the discussion... So just a remainder that we can deduct reasonable lynches even on Day1!
Eonwe was just as terrifying opponent I have been telling all my WW-history people like him are. I was about to suggest that we make a double lynch to do away with him but then decided not as there was that unhappy double-lynch already... So bad judgement from me!
Boro was a bit too nice all the time. It really caught my attention. But there was nothing concrete to build a case on so I thought that I should be friendly with him even though I voiced my suspicions mildly in the open for others to take the point of them. I hoped, were he the wolf, that he would have slipped something on the Days to come and decided to openly lean on his innocence just not to get myself killed. Well done,
Boro!
On other matters:
Lommy is just the great seer! According to my lorebooks, she is only second to
Boro! And her cool-headed revelation was just vintage-style werewolfing. Absolutely beautiful!
Although, I'm not sure if you all noticed my calculation after
Lommy revealed herself (#171). Had she been a wolf and
Di the real seer, the wolves would have won the game with us believing her story!
Di I feel really sorry about. She was just gearing up and had received
seerness and then was killed right out. She even made the right guess as a seer but had no chance to actually come forwards with it! That must have been frustrating, not the least when she was reading us trying to come up with her "seer-hints" after her death!
Celuien I kind of trusted from the very beginning and that seemed to be worthwhile again. But I totally forgot about this rule that the Ranger and the Hunter may discuss and thence know each other! Had I just noticed that ruling and I might have done a better work for the village. The fool that I am. The lesson: everytime, read the rules of the particular game...
Durelin I tended to trust even before the (false)
Di-revealment and did so to the end. Funny that some hunches actually work!
Folwren I must say acted a bit curiously in the beginning and here I agree with
Glirdy. But as she got definitively to defend herself, there was no question of her genuiness, at least to me. So sad she had to go that way... the worse of all ways, I say
But that brings me to
Glirdy. I was really lost with him. For one part I thought it was
Glirdy as usual, on the other I looked at his somewhat suspicious manouvers on the thread... But to double-lynch him!
And
Mac too I feel really sorry. He was - as
Di - just getting the hang of it, and after he was lynched on that
sorry Day (with
Glirdy &
Folwren) where many of us were not able to get online because of the BD collapse, it really felt unjustified.
In the end, before
Lommy's revealment, I really began to believe that from the gang of
Lommy,
The Ka and
Rune implicated by my interpretations of both
Di and
Volo would include at least one wolf. How much more wrong could one have been!
Rune really aroused some of my suspicions early in the game but seemed very reasonable towards the end of it.
The Ka I held a bit suspicious just because she was so reasonable. A contradiction? No. A werewolf game...
But yes. A good game everyone! I really enjoyed playing with you!