I have a few moments to spare and this caught my attention.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Roa_Aoife
Your point about Kuru is good, but I'd like to point out that your vote was thrown away. Nogrod was slated to die anyways, since we don't have double lynches, and he had reached the total first. The only ways he could have lived is if someone had voted for Eomer\, or someone else had retracted either their vote for Nogrod and voted elsewhere, or retracted and voted for Eomer, three things which were unlikely to happen. So all you did was vote for someone who was already about to be lynched. A nice way to avoid the appearance of throwing away while still throwing away.
|
I stand by my vote for Jenny, but this bit from Roa has me raising my eyebrow. Roa, do you honestly believe Jenny's vote was a throwaway? I can't say I agree with how Jenny voted knowing that she really didn't suspect Nogrod, but I'd hardly call that a throwaway vote simply because Nogrod was already set to die. It alarms me a bit you would say something like that Roa.
I've said before Jenny's vote was a bit odd and I still think it is, but Roa saying it was a throwaway vote is no less strange to me. If you were to label Jenny's vote for Nogrod as anything, I'd say it was a safe vote.
I smell something foul between these two and their voting.