....until the evil wizard is dead. Then it turns back into all the gamesmanship of werewolves cahooting at night.
This is the nature of Dueling Wizards Werewolf. It's one of its core elements. If I change this, it's not dueling wizards werewolf anymore.
The problem,
Lommy, with your primary, secondary, tertiary, or point award system is that the werewolves may nominate nine to sixteen different characters, three or four of whom are tied, or maybe less, but more often than not, it still ends up being the evil wizard's choice. Since that's the way it runs in my simpler system, I think I'll stick with simple.