the guy who be short:
post #'s 63, 158, 221, 225, 267, and 269
Really not much to go on. Most of it doesn't make much sense to me. He has been more active toDay, but only slightly. His vote for
morm seems to have some basis at least, although I do not like that half that base is tradition. Also, I'm rather confused by him, and his lack of valuable input is a big black mark in my mind.
Holbytlass:
post #'s 46, 69, 73, 79, 84, 128, 172, 177, 180, 211, and 247
First thing I noticed, her thoughts on everyone she puts forth in 69 and 70 are very sketchy and leave much to be desired. A couple of the comments seem back and forth. Not in itself too suspicious, though, as it was Day 1.
Shows a list of suspicion based on bluffs in post 79. Half the list is now proven innocent, and I think the others (including me) to be innocent. I don't like this because she seems to base suspicion on what I would deem banter, which, I guess, first day isn't all that bad since there's not much else to go on.
Ends up voting for
Nilp and says
Eomer bandwagon is spite.
Nilp was on her list, but I really think we'd gotten used to
Nilp being suicidal, and the idea that it's a bluff just doesn't jive with me.
In #128, she spends most of the time talking about
Jenny seeming suspicious, then doesn't put her on the her suspect list. Seems flip-floppish to me. And then she posts her suspect list in 172, and
Jenny is on it.
Post 211 she votes for
Lhuna. I wouldn't find this too strange, except that her only reason is self-preservation. Which I don't think too highly off because it seems that a wolf rather than an innocent would be worried about surviving.
Now, she gives a list, based on voting, in post 247. Personally, I love lists from voting, except her list is about vote placement. I think that vote placement is based more on timezones than being a wolf.
Overall, it's a lot of bits and pieces that don't add up to a whole lot. The feeling I'm getting, though, as opposed to
Guy, is that she seems to be trying to have a presence without really adding a lot to the discussion.
Guy's just not there, but
Holbytlass seems there in word, but not in deed, if you get what I mean.
On an unrelated note, I agree with morm about
Glirdan. I've not noticed it too much before, but this last statement really caught me as a set-up.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Glirdan
There's something that does not sit right with me about that Man [Saucepan]. I swear, if he's not dead toNight, I will be quite surprised and really suspicious.
|
I think I'll go through
Glirdan's posts real fast before I vote. If I had to vote now, I'd probably go with
Holby.