Kath – Day 1 banter, says day going badly for her, surprised by Eomer’s death, suspicious of Jenny. No verdict on her yet; I’ll wait to see what else she comes up with.
Jenny - banter, not sure about Sauce, mildly worried about Gurthang, wonders where Nilp is, clarification, says bandwagons against Eomer and Nilp are fishy, votes for Holby to save Nilp and Eomer, says Day 1's can be productive, "I told you so," suspicious of Form, Gurthang, Firefoot, apologizes for attempted bandwagon against Holby, categorical analysis halving the field in which she will look for wolves. She's definitely an interesting one. Generally speaking, I've found that the ones that get most worked up over things are innocent, although Jenny is a clever enough player to bluff that. Right now, she seems likely to be innocent and the accusations against her mostly circumstantial. The thoughts of her being the Hunter don't seem far-fetched to me, either.
Lalaith - General Day 1 comments, says Nilp is acting Nilp-ish, not comfortable with Formen, not sure of bandwagons for Eomer and Nilp, votes Formen, wonders why wolves killed Eomer, says grudge kill is unlikely, finds Glirdan's analyses interesting. I can definitely see an argument for her trying to slip under the radar... she posts fairly frequently, and while her posts aren't really short, they don't necessarily seem to say a whole lot. She sounds very iffy on the points of voting for Nilp to save Eomer and saying neither really seem guilty to her (this is probably bad logic since that could probably be said for a lot of people, so maybe this is just a bad feeling...). I don't know... I'm rather wary of her.
Diamond - Lots of banter, habitual vote for Eomer, finds it ironic that Nilp bandwagon seemed largely to save Eomer, provides first post stats. All I can say is that the way Diamond is playing right now would be a very easy way for a wolf to hide. She hasn't really made much serious contribution to the game yet at all. I'm borderline on her.
Gurthang - Biblical and PotC references, bantering with jesting accusations thrown in, wants to watch Taliesin, finds votes for Eomer odd, Lalaith, Eomer, Nilp not really suspicious, votes for Diamond as a voter for Eomer, annoyed about Nilp having been gifted, not really minding Eomer's death, wants to look at Nilp and Eomer voters, general comments about Nilp and Eomer, confused by Morm, wants a look at Formen, dislikes comments against Jenny. He has made some good points and mostly seems sensible, but I have little doubt he could do that as a wolf as well. For the time being though, I'm leaning innocent on him... nothing really jumps out as wolvish. The Corinithians reference seems almost too obvious for him to be a lover... unless he's bluffing. I could see that. If he's anything, he's a lover.
Formen - dislikes Day 1's, tempted to vote for himself, votes for Lalaith because she voted for him, speculation on Eomer's death, mild defense of his vote. He seems to be behaving rather oddly. I don't know what to make of him; apathetic and detached seem to best describe him.
Glirdan - Banter, vote for Kath, says Eomer was too smart to leave around, thinks it more likely that there is a wolf in Eomer's voters than Nilp's, analyses of Eomer's voters. He seems to be acting fairly sensible; his posts brought up a few good points. If he is a wolf, though, I would definitely look at Nilp's voters closer and assume that there is at least one wolf there. Borderline.
Rune - banter, early vote for Eomer, confused by Eomer's death and many votes for Nilp, not sure about Jenny, analysis post. Mostly he seems to me like an innocent blundering along and not really sure what to think. I don't see a whole lot that looks guilty about him; he just seems to unsure of everything to be a wolf.
Morm - Day 1 type accusations, extremely early vote for Glirdan, dislikes Eomer bandwagon, Day 2 immediate vote for Ang - which I still find odd, however good his reasoning is - says Glirdan is probably also guilty, further accusations against Ang, finds Glirdan's idea to not look very closely at Nilp's voters very suspect, responses and list of gut instinct reactions. Morm is behaving very oddly. Between his early votes and apparent unwillingness to really even consider those other than the ones he has hi-lighted... I don't know. If he's an innocent, what the heck...? I would not be surprised if he had some kind of secret... seer, lover, wolf, whatever. I don't know. I could go just about any way possible with him.
<Ahh! So many of you! Only four left...>
Taliesin - banter, jesting mistrust of Sauce, wants to trust Sauce, says voting for Nilp seems like the easiest thing to do, says Jenny seems to be trying to rescue a fellow wolf (Eomer), votes Eomer. I'm not really sure what to think about him yet. Borderline.
Saucepan - [Sorry, he just says way too much to be easily summarized here...] He has said lots of sensible things, as per the norm, and I find myself trusting him, also as per the norm... um... if he's a wolf, we're screwed?
(Okay, this probably looks guilty, not analyzing him like everyone else, but I'm getting tired of these and he does say a lot.)
<Okay, I don't really feel like doing this for Ang or tgwbs, either. No summaries for them, just reflections as I go along>
Anguirel - I find his vote fundamentally similar to Holby's in that they both had other suspects that they wanted to lynch but went with Nilp to save Eomer. I'm not entirely comfortable with Ang's vote (less comfortable than Holby's, at any rate); with more than half the people left to vote, there was still time for anything to happen. (Actually, now that I think of it, I'm not comfortable with Sauce's just letting Ang go, nor others who are doing so...) I like his point early on Day 2 about how wolves might have tried to vote for other people than Eomer and Nilp in order to appear more innocent themselves (it would be working, too - look where most of the blame is going today - to Nilp's and Eomer's voters). I don't know what to think about Ang. I don't want to lynch him today, but he's not off my suspect list, either. I am ready to go either way with him, depending on how things continue to develop.
tgwbs - another one of those who voted early for Eomer without apparent cause. Like Ang, he makes the point to look at those outside of Eomer/Nilp voters. He hasn't posted much at all, making it difficult to get a reading on him, and for that reason I'll say borderline leaning innocent.
I need a break now. Will be back...