I know I said I wasn't going to respond anymore, but...
Quote:
|
That's not a meaning. That's an attempt to dodge the issue.
|
That's why I said "meaning behind the post" and not "meaning of the post". Maybe meaning was a bad word.
The amazing thing is that I still think Roa is probably innocent. In fact, I am becoming increasingly convinced of this. I've seen too many spats like this one between innocents to think otherwise.
I need to sit back and look at the wider picture again.
I've gone back and looked at Boromir's innocent list (on which I still think there is probably a penguin), and of Macalaure Eonwe, Spawn, and Valier, I think that Macalaure is the most likely to be innocent, for reasons others and I have already stated. Next is Spawn. What few posts she has made have felt extremely innocent to me, and she made some good points in her posts. Although, her suspicions of Ang really catch my eye, probably because both the people I have really suspected so far (Encai and Valier) and Boromir have all suspected Ang (or in Encai's case, more tried to bring attention to him). I'd like to hear more from her. Eonwe puzzles me. I couldn't get anything clear from his very few posts. I think it's safe to say that both he and Valier are not wolves. Valier, I still think is suspicious. Right now, she is definitely one of my prospects for voting.
In his second list, Diamond still feels innocent to me, leaving Encai and Naria. I went back and looked at Naria again, and she really hasn't said much at all. I have no idea about her - I find it odd that Valier keeps coming back and mentioning her. Gut feeling is one thing, but Naria has posted all of five times, and said not much at all. I really would like to know where this comes from. It makes me wonder if maybe it's a Valier-Naria alliance rather than Valier-Encai as I was thinking before.
I see my vote going to Valier, Encai, Naria, or Eonwe. Maybe Spawn if something comes up. I think that there is definitely at least one wolf in this bunch; maybe even two.